Best ESR meter/What to look for

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Misterkeeks
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2013
    • 74
    • America

    #1

    Best ESR meter/What to look for

    I am looking to buy an ESR meter that will mainly be used for testing caps on monitors and their power supply boards. I would be doing this as a hobby. What would be a good ESR meter to purchase, and what specifications should I look for on one. Cost is an issue. Cheaper = better for now.
  • Kiriakos GR
    Banned
    • May 2012
    • 940
    • Greece

    #2
    Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

    How about reading most messages in this forum section, and return to this thread with more specific questions later on?

    Comment

    • Misterkeeks
      Senior Member
      • Nov 2013
      • 74
      • America

      #3
      Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

      This is really cheap. Why is that?

      Comment

      • dj_ricoh
        Badcaps Legend
        • Jan 2013
        • 2073
        • uk

        #4
        Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

        i got a fluke 175 and i think that its good for beginning and later when you advance
        Just cook it! It's already broken.

        Comment

        • Misterkeeks
          Senior Member
          • Nov 2013
          • 74
          • America

          #5
          Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

          Originally posted by dj_ricoh
          i got a fluke 175 and i think that its good for beginning and later when you advance
          Thank you. However, that one is way out of my budget. So far I am looking at an ESR Micro w/out a case, or the one linked above that I am suspicious about.

          Comment

          • Uniballer
            Badcaps Veteran
            • Jul 2013
            • 334
            • USA

            #6
            Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

            Originally posted by dj_ricoh
            i got a fluke 175 and i think that its good for beginning and later when you advance
            That is a good general purpose multimeter for voltage, current, resistance, etc., but it will not measure capacitor ESR (equivalent series resistance).

            Comment

            • domas
              News Hater
              • May 2013
              • 323
              • Denmark

              #7
              Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

              Originally posted by Misterkeeks
              i have one similar to this also cheapo chinese meter.

              http://www.ebay.com/itm/321203527074...84.m1439.l2649 thats mine

              doesn't measure esr if it is low, thus most caps can't be measured for esr.

              Capacitance and inductance is OK

              Comment

              • Misterkeeks
                Senior Member
                • Nov 2013
                • 74
                • America

                #8
                Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                Originally posted by domas
                i have one similar to this also cheapo chinese meter.

                http://www.ebay.com/itm/321203527074...84.m1439.l2649 thats mine

                doesn't measure esr if it is low, thus most caps can't be measured for esr.

                Capacitance and inductance is OK
                So if the ESR is low, it can't be measured. However, in a situation where the ESR is high, would an accurate ESR value be displayed, so I could at least find which capacitors are obviously bad?

                Comment

                • domas
                  News Hater
                  • May 2013
                  • 323
                  • Denmark

                  #9
                  Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                  i am not sure. I have tested some of caps, iirc the lowest i have seen was 0,1ohm

                  haven't used it much though. And i do not have a shitload of experience when it comes to ESR.

                  Comment

                  • Pinhead
                    Member
                    • Nov 2013
                    • 28
                    • United States

                    #10
                    Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                    "Low" ESR is a relative term of which I have yet to find a "standard" definition...

                    Comment

                    • Kiriakos GR
                      Banned
                      • May 2012
                      • 940
                      • Greece

                      #11
                      Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                      Originally posted by Pinhead
                      "Low" ESR is a relative term of which I have yet to find a "standard" definition...
                      One very compact in size definition requires from the listener to be in a relatively high educational level, so to be capable to use the information.

                      In simple English... how old are you?

                      Comment

                      • Misterkeeks
                        Senior Member
                        • Nov 2013
                        • 74
                        • America

                        #12
                        Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                        Originally posted by Pinhead
                        "Low" ESR is a relative term of which I have yet to find a "standard" definition...
                        Originally posted by Kiriakos GR
                        One very compact in size definition requires from the listener to be in a relatively high educational level, so to be capable to use the information.

                        In simple English... how old are you?
                        I think it's pretty clear what Pinhead meant.

                        Comment

                        • Pinhead
                          Member
                          • Nov 2013
                          • 28
                          • United States

                          #13
                          Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                          Originally posted by Kiriakos GR
                          One very compact in size definition requires from the listener to be in a relatively high educational level, so to be capable to use the information.

                          In simple English... how old are you?
                          I'm 30. Graduated with a BS in Electronics Engineering Technology at DeVRY University almost a decade ago. Unfortunately I haven't had a job in the electronics industry since then so I'm a little rusty.

                          Originally posted by Misterkeeks
                          I think it's pretty clear what Pinhead meant.
                          Thank you for being able to read statements within context.

                          For the more dense and less fluent in the English language: I meant it seems a bit ridiculous that with the sensitivity of equipment being designed and manufactured, and with seemingly minute changes in components having the possibility of making a huge difference in the operational stability of various circuits, that a term like "Low ESR" is so often used and yet never defined. Of course I know what ESR is. But, High ESR and Low ESR are pretty ambiguous terms.

                          It has been mentioned that many manufacturers define the terms so differently, that one MFG's high ESR cap can be another MFG's low ESR cap.

                          I somewhat assumed (incorrectly?) that a web forum which specializes in capacitor replacement -- aptly named Badcaps, no less -- would have a more solid definition hashed out if for no other reason than to facilitate effective communication across the forum.
                          Last edited by Pinhead; 11-19-2013, 09:02 AM.

                          Comment

                          • Toasty
                            Badcaps Legend
                            • Jul 2007
                            • 4171

                            #14
                            Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                            These discussions have been a part of this forum from the onset.

                            Trying to get > 60 different cap manufacturers to agree on what is "Low ESR" is nigh impossible. There is no industry wide standard. Mix all of it together and throw in some marketing and you'll have a better chance of getting a bill through Congress.

                            Low ESR -generally- means one that is to be used in SMPS and motherboard filtering. It is a term used to differentiate them from the "general purpose" caps.

                            There is no hard/firm definition and it is based upon the final purposing of the cap. A low ESR cap for motherboards is typically in the 5 mOhm (0.005Ī©) or less category. In SMPS, it would be in the 60 mOhm (0.060Ī©) or less.

                            That being said, I use the Blue ESR meter, built from the kit.

                            There is another one that some here use, but I don't know the name. Rather small and seemed of good construction. There was also one from a Russian fellow (IIRC) that some said was decent. A perusal of the forums for ESR meter suggestions will show all of them

                            T

                            Found the other 2: Atlas ESR70 and ESR Micro by RusMike

                            Check this too. He does a lot of equipment reviews: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZ49GCnf0V4

                            .
                            Last edited by Toasty; 11-19-2013, 09:39 AM.
                            veritas odium parit

                            Comment

                            • budm
                              Badcaps Legend
                              • Feb 2010
                              • 40746
                              • USA

                              #15
                              Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                              When you design the circuit, the ESR become part of the design requirement.
                              See post 8 for example:
                              https://www.badcaps.net/forum/showth...999#post300999

                              Too low or too high can be problem also.
                              Last edited by budm; 11-19-2013, 10:45 AM.
                              Never stop learning
                              Basic LCD TV and Monitor troubleshooting guides.
                              http://www.badcaps.net/forum/showthr...956#post305956

                              Voltage Regulator (LDO) testing:
                              http://www.badcaps.net/forum/showthr...999#post300999

                              Inverter testing using old CFL:
                              http://www.badcaps.net/forum/showthr...er+testing+cfl

                              Tear down pictures : Hit the ">" Show Albums and stories" on the left side
                              http://s807.photobucket.com/user/budm/library/

                              TV Factory reset codes listing:
                              http://www.badcaps.net/forum/showthread.php?t=24809

                              Comment

                              • Kiriakos GR
                                Banned
                                • May 2012
                                • 940
                                • Greece

                                #16
                                Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                                Originally posted by Pinhead
                                a) I'm 30. Graduated with a BS in Electronics Engineering Technology at DeVRY University almost a decade ago. Unfortunately I haven't had a job in the electronics industry since then so I'm a little rusty.

                                b)Thank you for being able to read statements within context.

                                c) But, High ESR and Low ESR are pretty ambiguous terms.
                                a) Good to know, I always like to give well targeted answers but not to kids.

                                b) I will never compete with you in poetry, no offense is taken all good in my camp.

                                c) Chemistry and new manufacturing techniques born the "Low ESR cap" which other than it practical value in pulsing power supply, the practical problem is their proper identification and test regarding failure.

                                Practically as long their internal resistance is very low, in order to measure it you need one proper instrument with the proper resolution in digits.
                                Anything with a resolution of four digits is good enough ( 0.000 ) but this luxury it is offered by true LCR meters which come from respectable manufacturers, and they are capable to be tested regarding calibration.
                                When measuring such low Ohm values the accuracy of the meter is extremely important.

                                Low resolution meters is gadgets of the past, therefore are very cheap to build.
                                Last edited by Kiriakos GR; 11-19-2013, 12:19 PM.

                                Comment

                                • phildan
                                  New Member
                                  • Nov 2013
                                  • 3
                                  • NEW ZEALAND

                                  #17
                                  Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                                  I have a "Peak" esr meter and find it good to use. I have a cheaper one - but not as cheap as the one you are looking at MK - and I can compare the two.

                                  Comment

                                  • Kiriakos GR
                                    Banned
                                    • May 2012
                                    • 940
                                    • Greece

                                    #18
                                    Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                                    Originally posted by phildan
                                    I have a "Peak" esr meter and find it good to use. I have a cheaper one - but not as cheap as the one you are looking at MK - and I can compare the two.
                                    In the planet Test & Measurement the under test device it should evaluated by a ten times better one, if the subject is an accuracy test.

                                    Those words are coming from the experts, I am just an electrician who follows the river flow and expand my knowledge.

                                    Comment

                                    • Misterkeeks
                                      Senior Member
                                      • Nov 2013
                                      • 74
                                      • America

                                      #19
                                      Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                                      Originally posted by phildan
                                      I have a "Peak" esr meter and find it good to use. I have a cheaper one - but not as cheap as the one you are looking at MK - and I can compare the two.
                                      If you could, that would be great!

                                      Originally posted by Kiriakos GR
                                      In the planet Test & Measurement the under test device it should evaluated by a ten times better one, if the subject is an accuracy test.

                                      Those words are coming from the experts, I am just an electrician who follows the river flow and expand my knowledge.
                                      While that may be true, I am just interested in why it is cheaper relative to the slightly more expensive models. Precision is not really my chief concern, and I only need enough precision to determine whether a cap is good/bad. Should the two meters give similar readings, I would purchase the cheaper option. Otherwise, I would opt for a more expensive/better meter.

                                      Comment

                                      • Kiriakos GR
                                        Banned
                                        • May 2012
                                        • 940
                                        • Greece

                                        #20
                                        Re: Best ESR meter/What to look for

                                        Originally posted by Misterkeeks
                                        While that may be true, I am just interested in why it is cheaper relative to the slightly more expensive models. Precision is not really my chief concern, and I only need enough precision to determine whether a cap is good/bad. Should the two meters give similar readings, I would purchase the cheaper option. Otherwise, I would opt for a more expensive/better meter.
                                        The capacitors manufacturer does not use an 100$ meter so to offer to us a comparison point due their datasheets.

                                        You may wish to paint your home white just with milk, but if you are up to making repairs you will follow the needed technical principals, or you just toying around, and in this case your opinion it can not taken seriously.
                                        Simple as that.

                                        Comment

                                        Related Topics

                                        Collapse

                                        • chth96
                                          Is it possible to test small ceramic disc capacitor with analogue meter?
                                          by chth96
                                          I read EBOOK of Testing Electronic Component and found that

                                          "In order to test the small blue resin coated ceramic disk capacitor which has 104 50v specification,it is possible to test this small ceramic capacitor by making use of analogue meter.
                                          Set to times 10Kohm that has 12v output from the probe to check disorder of ceramic capacitor.
                                          It is not uncommon that testing result of digital capacitance meter is okay,But It show shorted reading when you check it with analogue meter."

                                          Is it really possible to test small ceramic disc capacitor with analogue...
                                          03-09-2024, 10:03 PM
                                        • sam_sam_sam
                                          Modification of a Fluke multi meter that uses three AA batteries to use a 14500 lithium ion battery
                                          by sam_sam_sam
                                          I have had with regular AA batteries that leak this meter is expensive new I already replaced the battery battery clips once and the same thing happened again and I am tried of so it is getting modified to accommodate lithium ion batteries that are the same size excluding the positive terminal and removing the battery clips I will have enough room for the BMS protection board

                                          I going to put 3 lithium ion battery in parallel with the BMS protection board and a way to charge the battery externally and heat shrink the battery pack and use a JST connector so I easily remove the battery...
                                          12-31-2023, 06:04 AM
                                        • jorpec
                                          Changing the scale of an analog meter
                                          by jorpec
                                          Hi

                                          I want to change the scale of an analog meter, to monitor the charge of an li-ion single cell, so the needle at the end would point 4.2 volts and the 0 on the meter would point 2.5 volts or so, i tried to add diodes or a zener in series with the meter but the changes of the ambient temperature also changes the voltage value on the meter
                                          I wonder how i can accomplish this so the meter would be precise at any temperature ?

                                          Thnaks
                                          01-23-2023, 10:37 AM
                                        • sam_sam_sam
                                          How an incandescent light and a ESR meter ** friend**have a machine blowing fuses
                                          by sam_sam_sam
                                          About a month ago we had a transformer jumper wire that burned in two different places between two transformers caused over $200 thousand dollars worth of damage to VFD drives at least 10 of them and a memory card and quite a few power supply as well

                                          Now we have most of the equipment that got damaged back up and running except a feeder that has issues and we are waiting for some parts for

                                          Now we also have another piece of equipment that was blowing fuses on the 110 volt controller switch circuit with the ā€œEā€ stops and one switching power (24 volt) supply and a transformer...
                                          12-14-2023, 07:45 PM
                                        • Stephan Mathers
                                          EDMI ATLAS MK10 Electronic Meter Discussion
                                          by Stephan Mathers
                                          Greetings, new guy here but always interested in the crazy universe of modding

                                          We just finished construction of around 25 vacation houses, all inside the same private area.
                                          Each house has 3phase power , and we bought an atlas MK10 meter for each house (25 meters total ! )

                                          The metering on a per-house basis is done privately. Its not done by a utility company. The utility company will only charge us for the total consumption of all 25 houses together.

                                          Id like to do a small modification on the firmware of our MK10 to make it easier identify each house's...
                                          05-20-2025, 09:09 AM
                                        • Loading...
                                        • No more items.
                                        Working...