Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
Inadvertent honesty.PeteS in CA
Power Supplies should be boring: No loud noises, no bright flashes, and no bad smells.
****************************
To kill personal responsibility, initiative or success, punish it by taxing it. To encourage irresponsibility, improvidence, dependence and failure, reward it by subsidizing it.
****************************
Comment
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
Originally posted by lti View PostI have one of those sitting on my desk.
(Not sure if i have to keep things PG here, so i'll play it "safe")I'm not a expert, I'm just doing my best.
Comment
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
Well, I just checked my salvaged capacitor collection and found a Rukycon capacitor. What initially tipped me off was the absence of a vent, then the wierd negative stripe (regular Rubycon shown for comparison). Real Rubycon shown is 5x11, but the Rukycon is a 5 or 7mm that they just threw the standard 105°C label on.
Measures 222uF with .88 ohms of resistance. Not sure if that's good or bad.
Comment
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
Do we add (possibly) defunct/bought out manufacturers that made capacitors in the 1970s or earlier?
Like Aerovox ... does not appear to be in business anymore, and 50 years later these capacitors are probably bad.
I just pulled a few "Cerco" branded caps that had really high ESR, IMHO even for "general purpose". Their capacitance weren't too far off and their leakage isn't all too horrible.
Comment
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
I had some Marcon made Illinois Caps and Nichicons (from around the 90s or so) that started leaking down their negative legs in storage, as the legs were starting to turn green and slimy near the bung. The Nichicon caps were mostly from the PL series, and were all never installed.I'm not a expert, I'm just doing my best.
Comment
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
Originally posted by RukyCon View PostI had some Marcon made Illinois Caps and Nichicons (from around the 90s or so) that started leaking down their negative legs in storage, as the legs were starting to turn green and slimy near the bung. The Nichicon caps were mostly from the PL series, and were all never installed.
I have a number of old Astec PSUs that use these (well, the PL series). But they still seem fine and the PSUs work. Being a don't fix it if it ain't broke type of guy, I haven't opted to replace those caps yet. Sooner or later though, I'll probably run into that issue, I'm sure.
Comment
-
Re: List of Bad Cap Manufacturers
And to think some people say Cheng/Chang/Chong+/-X is "decent"...
- OK, but which one is the genuine brand one among all of these impostures?
(Hint: it's a trick question... a very very trick question)
.
.
That said, I really have no idea which one I'd pick. Probably would have to put a bunch of papers with their names in a hat and draw one randomly. I'm sure the chance of any of these lasting any reasonable amount of time will be just about as random as my hat lottery.
Comment
Comment