Post your worthless and/or pointless repairs

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • прямо
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Sep 2022
    • 261
    • Indonesia

    #141
    My pointless and worthless repair is a 5V 3A switched mode power supply adaptor.

    What happened to it was a leaky main cap, and when I plugged, unplugged then quickly plugged back the adaptor, somehow that made the PWM chip blew itself up.

    The chip is OB2358AP. It cost about the same as a brand new adaptor, which is around $1.

    ​​​​​​I replaced the chip and the main leaky cap.
    It's been running fine since then.

    I also have another pointless and worthless repair.
    ​​​​​​A GTX 560 SE with missing components and ripped pads. Being an old DX11 card with only 1GB GDDR5, it has zero value, but I repaired it anyway.

    It's also running fine in one of my computers but I don't like the blower fan design, because it fails to cool down the VCORE mosfets. One of these days I will probably 3D print a shroud for it, that will allow me to mount a standard 90mm graphics card fan which I salvaged from a dead RTX.

    Comment

    • momaka
      master hoarder
      • May 2008
      • 12164
      • Bulgaria

      #142
      Originally posted by прямо
      My pointless and worthless repair is a 5V 3A switched mode power supply adaptor.

      What happened to it was a leaky main cap, and when I plugged, unplugged then quickly plugged back the adaptor, somehow that made the PWM chip blew itself up.

      The chip is OB2358AP. It cost about the same as a brand new adaptor, which is around $1.

      ​​​​​​I replaced the chip and the main leaky cap.
      It's been running fine since then.
      Good save!

      I don't think you can get a decent 5V 3 Amp power adapter like that for $1 new from the store.
      The one shown above is built very well - it has an input choke, proper fuse and thermistor, an and proper X2 and Y2 caps.
      All the cheapo adapters I can get new here (for more than $1, mind you) are gutless wonders with 1kV ceramic caps between primary and secondary, and a bunch of other cost-cutting measures.

      Originally posted by прямо
      I also have another pointless and worthless repair.
      ​​​​​​A GTX 560 SE with missing components and ripped pads. Being an old DX11 card with only 1GB GDDR5, it has zero value, but I repaired it anyway.
      For someone as far behind as I am on the hardware curve, I'd say a GTX 560 (be it SE or not) is still a very decent video card.
      What's funny is I find GTX 460 and 560 cards can now be found on Ebay for very cheap... yet try looking for a high-end DX 9.0 card, and the prices jump back up, sometimes to absurd levels. Not sure what the retro PC crowd is smoking these days, but a GTX560 is perfectly capable of handling any XP games at high res without the cost of an arm and a leg.
      Also, many modern game requirements are stupid high nowadays for no reason. (Well, it's not for no reason... the reason is that coders / game devs are not willing to optimized anything for the PC, because it's expected that people that play games will always have good hardware. But Xbox and PS4/5, it's a different story.)

      Originally posted by прямо
      It's also running fine in one of my computers but I don't like the blower fan design, because it fails to cool down the VCORE mosfets.
      The core appears to be running nice and cool, though - after all, 52C for GPU @ 100% load is not bad at all. I have the EVGA version on these cards (just regular GTX 560's) with the single fan in the middle, and those heatsinks designs suck even more. Sure my VRM MOSFETs might be getting cooled... but what good is that when the GPU core is running miserably hot?
      No thanks, I'll take a refference blower -style cooler any day. It also removes heat from the system (PC case) rather than just re-circulate hot air inside the case.

      BTW, you mentioned you fixed your card, but I see it's stuck in 1x PCI-E mode in GPU-Z. Is that because you're testing with an extension PCI-E cable (like those meant for mining rigs) or an error in GPU-Z? I have some dead/dying cards that also run only in 1x... or sometimes in 4x... but it's not due to bad ceramic caps near the PCI-E connector, I already checked. Most likely, it's a dying GPU in those cards.
      That said, if yours is connected directly to the motherboard's PCI-E 16x slot and still running in 1x only, check the other "non-damaged" ceramic caps to make sure they are not shorted.
      Whenever I see broken ceramic caps on a video card, I always assume it was not handled properly and thus any ceramic cap could be shorted. So for the ones on the PCI-E conn., I always check them all for short-circuit and proper capacitance. They should be either 100 nF or 220 nF.

      Comment

      • прямо
        Badcaps Veteran
        • Sep 2022
        • 261
        • Indonesia

        #143
        Originally posted by momaka
        Good save!

        I don't think you can get a decent 5V 3 Amp power adapter like that for $1 new from the store.
        I've seen better design from a $2 adapter believe it or not, and yeah, I bought this awhile back for $1. Price don't change for small power adapters like this.

        The core appears to be running nice and cool, though - after all, 52C for GPU @ 100% load is not bad at all. I have the EVGA version on these cards (just regular GTX 560's) with the single fan in the middle, and those heatsinks designs suck even more. Sure my VRM MOSFETs might be getting cooled... but what good is that when the GPU core is running miserably hot?
        No thanks, I'll take a refference blower -style cooler any day. It also removes heat from the system (PC case) rather than just re-circulate hot air inside the case.
        Yup, the core is cool and dandy but the mosfets aren't, they get very hot. I have two of these cards, with a reference blower and with a big fan in the middle. Both has the same core temp, but mosfets are not running hot on the one with the big fan.

        BTW, you mentioned you fixed your card, but I see it's stuck in 1x PCI-E mode in GPU-Z. Is that because you're testing with an extension PCI-E cable (like those meant for mining rigs)
        Correct. I took the screenshots with the card running on a 1X PCIe slot mining riser.

        And btw, a decent DX 9.0 card which is ATI HD 4870 1GB GDDR5 imho, cost about $3 but with a no display symptom, lol.
        If I do a retro gaming, I'd snatch that up and repair it.
        Last edited by прямо; 04-26-2024, 07:27 PM.

        Comment

        • прямо
          Badcaps Veteran
          • Sep 2022
          • 261
          • Indonesia

          #144
          Card runs at X16 PCIe 2.0 on an old AM3 motherboard

          Comment

          • eccerr0r
            Solder Sloth
            • Nov 2012
            • 8662
            • USA

            #145
            Have not forgotten:
            Click image for larger version  Name:	pointless.jpg Views:	0 Size:	156.0 KB ID:	3525103
            Why did I bother... I'm currently using secondhand units from a thrift shop that will never have this problem.

            Comment

            Related Topics

            Collapse

            • Nagy Daniel
              Lowest possible resistance on laptop motherboard rail - Guide Table request
              by Nagy Daniel
              Hi, I'm Daniel, and I'm new to the world of repairing motherboards.

              I would like to create a table, or more likely a guideline about the voltage rails and their possible resistance rail.

              I know that the motherboard design has a very big depend on the rail's resistance, but I would like to know what is the smallest value for a rail that can be acceptable. For example, I heard that some new gaming motherboards can have 0,5 Ohm resistance on the GPU rail, but on an older type, it could be a sign of a shorted GPU rail.

              So, I generated a table with AI so I can...
              03-04-2025, 08:24 AM
            • momaka
              HannStar Hanns-G HC194d LCD monitor repair
              by momaka
              Normally, I never post repairs this quick after I do them, because… I am usually very slow. But today, I’m making an exception here. Why? No idea. Perhaps only because the repair details are still “fresh” in my head… which is ironic, given this is a 16 year old monitor that hardly anyone will care about today. It is new to me, though. I picked it up last November from someone on my local Craigslist. It wasn’t very close to where I live, but was close to a family friend that I had to go visit anyways. So after watching the posting on Craigslist for a few weeks and seeing it getting...
              03-15-2023, 10:17 PM
            • Victor Moreira Silva
              Acer Nitro 5 LA-L181p power LED turns on by 5 secs (Short on PCH rail?)
              by Victor Moreira Silva
              Hello everyone,

              I'm trying to repair my old Acer Nitro 5 (AN517-54-55T5). I've already bought a new laptop, so this is more of a learning project. For the experience, with no high expectations of success.

              Well, my decice specs are the following:

              Model: Acer Nitro 5 AN517-54-55T5
              CPU: Intel Core i5-11400H
              GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1650
              Motherboard: GH51G LA-L181P Rev:1c

              The symptom:
              When pressing the power button, the power LED lights up for about 5 seconds and then turns off. Initially, the issue was intermittent: sometimes...
              05-26-2025, 10:49 AM
            • bimole
              Weird behavior on 3.3V rail of a CORSAIR CX600
              by bimole
              Hi,

              A colleague gave me an apparently ill CORSAIR CX600.
              He told me that he heard a banging noise, and smelt the magic smoke.
              After tearing down the PSU, no burnt component, everything seems OK, but the PSU often refuses to stay ON. When shorting PS_ON to GND, the fan spins a bit a finally stops. No output voltages.

              I tried to treat some apparently bad solder joins and finally it seems to work OK... on the 12V and 5V rails!
              It's another story on the 3.3V rail...

              I have some devices to test deeply PSUs (scope, AC source, electronic load)...
              02-13-2025, 04:49 AM
            • joshAU
              Acer AN515-55-528T FH52M LA-J891P - Short ciruit after PQW1 MOSFET on +1.35VSDGPU rail.
              by joshAU
              Hi all.
              This notebook was showing no signs of life.

              I removed the FH52M LA-J891P mainboard and found that there was 19V at the DC jack.
              However there was zero volts on the two PRB2 and PRB46 resistors immediately after the two polarity protection MOSFETs (PQB11 & PQB12).

              If I remove the PQW1 MOSFET, the 19V rail starts working, and I can turn on the unit - at least I get the fans, and the power light comes on, when I simulate the power button being pressed. No display.

              I tried replacing the MOSFET with a new one, but again no voltage on the...
              05-29-2024, 12:33 AM
            • Loading...
            • No more items.
            Working...