Building passive computer speakers

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • lti
    Badcaps Legend
    • May 2011
    • 2545
    • United States

    #1

    Building passive computer speakers

    I have two Peerless W3-LK76-PBK drivers that I want to use as computer speakers. The built-in amp in my old Compaq is the only amp I have that is capable of powering speakers with such low impedance (the actual impedance seems to be about three ohms). I plan on putting these speakers in small sealed boxes made of 1/2" plywood. The boxes will have internal dimensions of 4"x6.5"x2.5". Bass reproduction isn't an issue since these drivers don't produce much bass (less than all other 3" full-range drivers I have heard).

    Unfortunately, the speakers are not actually shielded and have strong magnets. Is it possible to add magnetic shielding?

    Are there any other problems with this design? I have the drivers and tons of wire, but I don't have any other parts yet.
  • dumpystig
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Jul 2011
    • 485
    • UK

    #2
    Re: Building passive computer speakers

    How about lining the inside of your boxes with aluminium kitchen foil? I reckon there has to be at least some benefit from doing this.
    System: HP xw6600 Workstation, 650W PSU | 2x Intel Xeon Quad E5440 @2.83GHz | 8x 1GB FB-DDR2 @ 667MHz | Kingston/Intel X25-M 160GB SSD | 2x 1TB Spinpoint F3, RAID0 | 1x 1TB Spinpoint F3, backup | ATI FireGL V7700 512MB | Sony Optiarc DVD +/-RW | Win 7 Ultimate x64 | 2x Dell UltraSharp U2410f | Dell E248WFP

    Comment

    • kaboom
      "Oh, Grouchy!"
      • Jan 2011
      • 2507
      • USA

      #3
      Re: Building passive computer speakers

      Aluminum foil won't block the static field from those magnets. Unless you are close to a CRT monitor or magnetic media of any kind, you don't even need shielded drivers.

      Znom is 4 ohms. DCR is 3.4 ohms, but the amp feeds them AC- you've got the reactance of the voice coil with increasing frequency. And the characteristics of the loudspeaker system will have an effect on the impedance as well.

      Any idea on the output power of that amp? It's something to keep in mind when you're starting with 85 dB W/M drivers. You may not need much with 'near-field' 'puter speakers.

      -Paul
      "pokemon go... to hell!"

      EOL it...
      Originally posted by shango066
      All style and no substance.
      Originally posted by smashstuff30
      guilty,guilty,guilty,guilty!
      guilty of being cheap-made!

      Comment

      • dumpystig
        Badcaps Veteran
        • Jul 2011
        • 485
        • UK

        #4
        Re: Building passive computer speakers

        Yeah you're right, I'm a fuckwit, duno what I was thinking
        System: HP xw6600 Workstation, 650W PSU | 2x Intel Xeon Quad E5440 @2.83GHz | 8x 1GB FB-DDR2 @ 667MHz | Kingston/Intel X25-M 160GB SSD | 2x 1TB Spinpoint F3, RAID0 | 1x 1TB Spinpoint F3, backup | ATI FireGL V7700 512MB | Sony Optiarc DVD +/-RW | Win 7 Ultimate x64 | 2x Dell UltraSharp U2410f | Dell E248WFP

        Comment

        • dood
          Deputy dood
          • Mar 2004
          • 2462
          • USA

          #5
          Re: Building passive computer speakers

          Do a search for bucking magnets on Parts Express. They cancel out the magnetic field that the magnets on the driver produce.
          Ludicrous gibs!

          Comment

          • lti
            Badcaps Legend
            • May 2011
            • 2545
            • United States

            #6
            Re: Building passive computer speakers

            Originally posted by kaboom
            Aluminum foil won't block the static field from those magnets. Unless you are close to a CRT monitor or magnetic media of any kind, you don't even need shielded drivers.

            Znom is 4 ohms. DCR is 3.4 ohms, but the amp feeds them AC- you've got the reactance of the voice coil with increasing frequency. And the characteristics of the loudspeaker system will have an effect on the impedance as well.

            Any idea on the output power of that amp? It's something to keep in mind when you're starting with 85 dB W/M drivers. You may not need much with 'near-field' 'puter speakers.

            -Paul
            The speakers will be placed next to a CRT monitor. One speaker will be placed close to the computer.

            The impedance seems to be less than four ohms. Any amp that is not designed to power speakers with an impedance lower than 4 ohms overheats or produces distorted sound.

            The amp is based on a TDA1515BQ IC and is powered from 12V. The output power should be around 5 watts into a 4 ohm speaker.
            Originally posted by dood
            Do a search for bucking magnets on Parts Express. They cancel out the magnetic field that the magnets on the driver produce.
            These drivers appear to already have bucking magnets, but they don't do much.

            Comment

            • kaboom
              "Oh, Grouchy!"
              • Jan 2011
              • 2507
              • USA

              #7
              Re: Building passive computer speakers

              No, the impedance is four ohms. The DCR is just that. Also, the coupling caps will limit what you can get with decreasing frequency. They are 1000uF in the app ckt in the datasheet.

              Don't sweat the impedance. Measure the primary of a large power transformer or induction motor. Usually less than an ohm to a few ohms- a dead short right? But their impedance is higher. Impedance is made up of reactance and resistance.

              Look for other drivers that have the shielding bell over the magnet. You don't necessarily need 4 ohm drivers if you do the math and determine you can reach your target SPL, based on the power you have and drivers's sensitivity. If the output rating of that amp is accurate, the following is true: 8-ohm drivers with 89 dB/W sensitivity will play as loud as the ones you suggested, -provided- your box makes them happy.

              You could always make your own mu-metal cans, but that would cost more than the drivers!

              -Paul
              "pokemon go... to hell!"

              EOL it...
              Originally posted by shango066
              All style and no substance.
              Originally posted by smashstuff30
              guilty,guilty,guilty,guilty!
              guilty of being cheap-made!

              Comment

              • lti
                Badcaps Legend
                • May 2011
                • 2545
                • United States

                #8
                Re: Building passive computer speakers

                I have started to build the boxes for these speakers. I have one almost complete. I just need to cut a hole for the driver and find some terminals. Also, I remembered that I suck at woodworking.

                If I had the money to spend on better drivers, I wouldn't be trying to make these drivers work.

                Comment

                • lti
                  Badcaps Legend
                  • May 2011
                  • 2545
                  • United States

                  #9
                  Re: Building passive computer speakers

                  I have one box finished and the glue is drying on the other box.

                  These will replace my cheap computer speakers.

                  Comment

                  • lti
                    Badcaps Legend
                    • May 2011
                    • 2545
                    • United States

                    #10
                    Re: Building passive computer speakers

                    I finished building these speakers. They sound as good as I expected.

                    Comment

                    Related Topics

                    Collapse

                    • Califauna
                      Help with boom box modification
                      by Califauna
                      Hi, this is more of a project help request than a troubleshooting question. I hope I can post it here.

                      I have a W-King D8 Bluetooth boom box which I'd like to modify with some external speaker output jacks and some buttons to switch the internal speakers on and off.

                      From factory the specs of the boom box are:

                      -Power Input: DC 5V
                      -Speaker Output Power: 2 x 25W ( confirmed by Youtube channel Hartdegen review as 12.5W RMS per channel)
                      -Drivers:
                      -2 x Woofer, 70mm, 10Ω, 70mm,15W
                      -2 X Tweeter, 8Ω, 30mm,10W x 2
                      -Frequency...
                      12-04-2021, 01:53 PM
                    • Widget
                      Logitech R20 speakers - Replacing one of the speakers.
                      by Widget
                      Hi guys,

                      I have a set of Logitech R20 speakers, one of the speakers wasn't working, so I took it apart & there was no continuity or Resistance when probing the Tinsel Wires. Plus looks like the speaker was exposed to liquid as there's rust on the metal speaker frame.

                      Just in case, I removed the other speaker and installed it in place of the damaged speaker to make sure the PCB of the damaged speaker was ok & it seemed to work fine, so it looks like it's just the speaker for now.

                      Printed on the back of the Logitech speaker is;

                      LOGITECH...
                      05-29-2024, 07:07 AM
                    • momaka
                      Panasonic Thrusters SB-250
                      by momaka
                      Found something really "interesting" 2 days ago while going to the grocery store. Not a best score by a long shot... but a fun one . I was actually first going to post that oldschool case that I mentioned in my previous post, but this one is on mind mind at the moment. Oh, I am like a teenage school girl – I can barely contain myself now.

                      So what I found was… okay, please give me just a few more moments to stop giggling here
                      .
                      .
                      .
                      The Panasonic THRUSTERS
                      Now now kids, let’s not make fun of our names or...
                      10-05-2018, 07:20 AM
                    • RetroComputingGrotto
                      Behringer MS16 Speakers - Low Volume on One Speaker
                      by RetroComputingGrotto
                      I've had a set of speakers come in with the fault of not powering on.

                      I could hear something wrattling around in the speakers so we played a game called Guess What's In The Speakers! and this is what we found:



                      1 random loose nut and part of a BIC Biro pen.

                      After removing these foreign objects I plugged in the speaker and powered it on and found the volume to be quite low. On plugging in the other speaker it was very loud, but only out of the other speaker, this side was still very low.







                      ...
                      05-20-2024, 07:29 AM
                    • japlytic
                      DRIVER_PNP_WATCHDOG error re. old drivers in Windows 11 install image
                      by japlytic
                      In a Beelink GTR mini PC, mine has an Intel AX200NGW WLAN module.

                      Tried (only with keyboard/mouse connected):
                      • BIOS + database update
                      • Using latest Windows 11 image built with official image creation tool
                      • Previous setup version for Windows 11 installer
                      • Replacing SSD without a slow block (the previous SSD had a slow block with access time > 500 mS)
                      • TPM reset (worked to the point where DRIVER_PNP_WATCHDOG error message is displayed briefly after the point of stalling)
                      • Disabling power to WLAN and LAN modules in BIOS (Advanced > AMD PBS > PCI Express Configuration)
                      ...
                      06-19-2025, 04:59 PM
                    • Loading...
                    • No more items.
                    Working...