I suspect the cap(s) immediately next to the large bundle of cables coming into the PSU. I'm thinking mechanical action/stress/movement has "done something" to the caps, as one of them in particular is REALLY wobbly. It won't rotate, so it feels like both leads are still intact, but you can't really see anything so IDK. Wonder if caps can go bad due to movement stress where the lead stays unbroken, but the cap is broken anyways.
Also, there is another thread (which I've read) on badcaps here. Mine is a 520 Watt and that one is a 420 and the components look different although the overall design looks the same. Cap manufacturers are different.
Did a several thorough visual inspections top, side & bottom, multiple times and I've gone through 3 different cameras trying to get the best possible resolution, which I'll call "adequate".
I can find no evidence of burning, heat, leaking, bulging, nor any other defect that might indicate a problem, but the PSU won't work. It killed one motherboard and I got stupid and put it in another and luckily the PSU died before it killed another motherboard. From what I've read, when caps go bad they allow "ripple" which I assume is variation in voltage and that is really bad for motherboard caps, and that is (one way at least) how bad PSU's kill motherboards.
So caps are on the list of suspects. I have a few ideas on how to troubleshoot this, but would rather get the 1st step, basic advice first before going off on some wild tangent. This particular repair is stemming from a post I made several days ago asking if, in general, repairing PSU's for money is worth doing, and the consensus was "not really", but for the sake of personal development and a little side money. This is the best of the 20 or so PSU's I have laying around, so I thought I'd invest my time & energy into the one that would give the most bang for the buck, compared to the numerous POS PSU's that, even when repaired are still POS's.
As usual, I appreciate all help, even misguided attempts at help. This will be the 4th piece of electronics I've successfully repaired (if successful) based on knowledge and help I've received on this forum, and I remain appropriately appreciative of that. As an aside, I spent almost a full year in the USCM ground radio repair school learning to troubleshoot and repair military radios to the component level and once graduated, spent the remainder of my 4 year contract and never touched a soldering iron.
They used to tell us it cost in the neighborhood of $100,000 to train us, and how appreciative we were supposed to be, and then we never used a single dime's worth of that training. Now, 25 years later I've put that background to use for the 1st time ever, and have repaired more equipment in the last 2 months than I did in 3 years in the USMC.
To give you-all a sense of perspective about "military training" vs. online educational opportunities. And also where you tax payer dollars go. They could probably send those jarheads here, and save the taxpayers millions, is my point.
Also, there is another thread (which I've read) on badcaps here. Mine is a 520 Watt and that one is a 420 and the components look different although the overall design looks the same. Cap manufacturers are different.
Did a several thorough visual inspections top, side & bottom, multiple times and I've gone through 3 different cameras trying to get the best possible resolution, which I'll call "adequate".
I can find no evidence of burning, heat, leaking, bulging, nor any other defect that might indicate a problem, but the PSU won't work. It killed one motherboard and I got stupid and put it in another and luckily the PSU died before it killed another motherboard. From what I've read, when caps go bad they allow "ripple" which I assume is variation in voltage and that is really bad for motherboard caps, and that is (one way at least) how bad PSU's kill motherboards.
So caps are on the list of suspects. I have a few ideas on how to troubleshoot this, but would rather get the 1st step, basic advice first before going off on some wild tangent. This particular repair is stemming from a post I made several days ago asking if, in general, repairing PSU's for money is worth doing, and the consensus was "not really", but for the sake of personal development and a little side money. This is the best of the 20 or so PSU's I have laying around, so I thought I'd invest my time & energy into the one that would give the most bang for the buck, compared to the numerous POS PSU's that, even when repaired are still POS's.
As usual, I appreciate all help, even misguided attempts at help. This will be the 4th piece of electronics I've successfully repaired (if successful) based on knowledge and help I've received on this forum, and I remain appropriately appreciative of that. As an aside, I spent almost a full year in the USCM ground radio repair school learning to troubleshoot and repair military radios to the component level and once graduated, spent the remainder of my 4 year contract and never touched a soldering iron.
They used to tell us it cost in the neighborhood of $100,000 to train us, and how appreciative we were supposed to be, and then we never used a single dime's worth of that training. Now, 25 years later I've put that background to use for the 1st time ever, and have repaired more equipment in the last 2 months than I did in 3 years in the USMC.
To give you-all a sense of perspective about "military training" vs. online educational opportunities. And also where you tax payer dollars go. They could probably send those jarheads here, and save the taxpayers millions, is my point.
Comment