what happens when you use a weak PSU?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • pentium
    Badcaps Legend
    • Mar 2006
    • 2778
    • Canada

    #1

    what happens when you use a weak PSU?

    Okay, so I got myself the Sapphire HD 3850 and on the box it says it needs a 450W or better PSU with at least 18A in the 12V rail.
    I look at my Thermaltake PSU and it's only a 430W box with just 18A on the 12V rail.
    Assuming I plugged this card into my system, what exactly would happen?
    Melting wires?
    Smoke?
    Computer self-destructs?
    Blown fuse?
    What bad things can come from overloading your PSU?
    Find Nedry!


    Check the Vending machines!!

    <----Computer says I need more beer.
  • acstech
    GrumpyModerator
    • Jul 2007
    • 1432
    • USA

    #2
    Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

    The PSU goes out of spec on ripple on the overloaded lines, and takes out capacitors, destabilizes the computer, etc.

    Either that, or the voltage goes down too much causing other bad things to happen.

    Since the +12v line is ok with the required 18A, I'd say you'll be ok. Having not looked at a TT PSU I couldn't really say for certain though.

    I would run it through 3dmark06 once and check voltages. If they're within spec and aren't dropping too much with load I wouldn't bother replacing it.

    If you want to replace it, take a look at this:

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16817151034
    Last edited by acstech; 08-30-2008, 07:15 PM.
    A man convinced against his will is of the same opinion still.

    Comment

    • gdement
      Badcaps Veteran
      • Jan 2007
      • 690

      #3
      Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

      Those requirements are just a best guess by the card manufacturer, so if you have a good PSU and the system isn't heavily loaded by other stuff, then you're probably fine. I'm not sure how conservative they are when they write those requirements.

      Comment

      • pentium
        Badcaps Legend
        • Mar 2006
        • 2778
        • Canada

        #4
        Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

        Whoops, my mistake.
        Actually the card needs 30A on the 12V rail and my PSU can only deliver 18A.
        Find Nedry!


        Check the Vending machines!!

        <----Computer says I need more beer.

        Comment

        • stevo1210
          Badcaps Legend
          • Oct 2006
          • 4156
          • Australia

          #5
          Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

          If it requires 30A and you only have 18A on the 12V line... it is possible that the MOSFETs etc. will start to burn up. But seeing as this is a Thermaltake PSU, it will probably have a safety cut out before anything goes wrong. I have a Thermaltake as well and they are well built.
          Don't find love, let love find you. That's why its called falling in love, because you don't force yourself to fall, you just fall. - Anonymous

          Comment

          • Scenic
            o.O
            • Sep 2007
            • 2642
            • Germany

            #6
            Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

            well... i tried to use a 250W Fortron (recapped) in my P4 sys as i didn't have stronger PSUs at hand at that time..

            it's my testing system for almost everything...

            after adding some HDDs and a GF6600 it randomly locked up (total freeze) or shut down (as if you unplug the power)...

            replacing it with a 400W Delta Electronics solved the problems

            oh.. and the voltages with the forton were extremely flaky... and the psu fan was running on top speed all the time.. but still didnt manage to keep the psu cool enough (could barely touch it )

            wires were "cold" though.. no melting or something..

            Comment

            • pentium
              Badcaps Legend
              • Mar 2006
              • 2778
              • Canada

              #7
              Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

              Well then.
              I guess when I go and look for two matching 500Gb Sata drives I'll also have to be looking for a new PSU as well.
              Find Nedry!


              Check the Vending machines!!

              <----Computer says I need more beer.

              Comment

              • zandrax
                Hit and miss
                • Dec 2007
                • 1157
                • Italy

                #8
                Re: what happens when you use a weak PSU?

                I think your 3850 don't really draw 30 A on the 12 V line: it'd be a 360 W consumption for the videocard alone, you'd hear a turbojet-like fan spinning at 12000 rpm all day . WOOOOOOOSH!
                These are power requirements for an high loaded system and for cheap psus with fake ratings on their labels: AMD and nVidia are well aware than, in best case, most people simply read the psu labels, check only wattage and buy the cheapest one with the wattage they need (in worst case they skip the first part and buy the cheapest at all), so they make high requirements to avoid people returning a new card burned by a sub-average grade smps with fake "500 W" labels.
                If you read any review, you'd discover that most mid level gaming systems draw near 200W at load, so the 30A requirements is unreasonable according to mere consumption. I think the 3850 shouldn't draw more than 80-90 W at full load, so 7-8 A on the 12 V line.
                What exact Thermaltake model do you own? IIRC, Thoughpower ones are CWT and are decent, rated quite near their limits (so a 430 W is a good 350-400 one); Purepower and TR/TR2 are made by other manifacturers and they don't deliver what they promise. Check reviews at Jonnyguru, it may be listed here.

                Zandrax
                Have an happy life.

                Comment

                Related Topics

                Collapse

                • Nagy Daniel
                  Lowest possible resistance on laptop motherboard rail - Guide Table request
                  by Nagy Daniel
                  Hi, I'm Daniel, and I'm new to the world of repairing motherboards.

                  I would like to create a table, or more likely a guideline about the voltage rails and their possible resistance rail.

                  I know that the motherboard design has a very big depend on the rail's resistance, but I would like to know what is the smallest value for a rail that can be acceptable. For example, I heard that some new gaming motherboards can have 0,5 Ohm resistance on the GPU rail, but on an older type, it could be a sign of a shorted GPU rail.

                  So, I generated a table with AI so I can...
                  03-04-2025, 08:24 AM
                • Victor Moreira Silva
                  Acer Nitro 5 LA-L181p power LED turns on by 5 secs (Short on PCH rail?)
                  by Victor Moreira Silva
                  Hello everyone,

                  I'm trying to repair my old Acer Nitro 5 (AN517-54-55T5). I've already bought a new laptop, so this is more of a learning project. For the experience, with no high expectations of success.

                  Well, my decice specs are the following:

                  Model: Acer Nitro 5 AN517-54-55T5
                  CPU: Intel Core i5-11400H
                  GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1650
                  Motherboard: GH51G LA-L181P Rev:1c

                  The symptom:
                  When pressing the power button, the power LED lights up for about 5 seconds and then turns off. Initially, the issue was intermittent: sometimes...
                  05-26-2025, 10:49 AM
                • lefetylorant
                  Lenovo Thinkcentre tiny M90Q gen 1 - no 12V rail
                  by lefetylorant
                  Hello Everyone,

                  Long story short, I got this unit for very cheap.
                  I've started to experiment with it's BIOS, as I did before successfully with an M900. However my very bad quality SOIC clip broken while dumping of the biosof and it must have damaged something on the panel, because it does not turn on, and does exactly nothing when powered. The maximum voltage that could have affected something is the 3.3 or 5v from the IC clip, because the unit was not powered while the bios dumping was in progress.

                  I've performed some measurements:
                  - 20V rail perfectly...
                  09-14-2023, 05:05 AM
                • bimole
                  Weird behavior on 3.3V rail of a CORSAIR CX600
                  by bimole
                  Hi,

                  A colleague gave me an apparently ill CORSAIR CX600.
                  He told me that he heard a banging noise, and smelt the magic smoke.
                  After tearing down the PSU, no burnt component, everything seems OK, but the PSU often refuses to stay ON. When shorting PS_ON to GND, the fan spins a bit a finally stops. No output voltages.

                  I tried to treat some apparently bad solder joins and finally it seems to work OK... on the 12V and 5V rails!
                  It's another story on the 3.3V rail...

                  I have some devices to test deeply PSUs (scope, AC source, electronic load)...
                  02-13-2025, 04:49 AM
                • mkdj
                  Acer TravelMate P214 - N19Q7 main power rail shorted to ground
                  by mkdj
                  Dear all,

                  I have taken out the motherboard of a Acer TravelMate P214. There is a short to ground on the main power rail (19V). I don't have the schematics or boardview for this board (DAZ8IMB1AA0 REVA). But I have found 4 MOSFETS close to the main power rail : 2 N-Channel and 2 P-Channel.

                  I have checked resistance across each of the 4 MOSFETS. I have the following readings:
                  Both N-Channel Mosfets: nothing odd

                  P-Channel MOSFET number 1:
                  source - drain : 117 kOhm
                  source - gate: 96 Ohm
                  gate - drain: 117 kOhm


                  P-Channel MOSFET...
                  08-20-2025, 06:08 AM
                • Loading...
                • No more items.
                Working...