CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Rippa_MD
    New Member
    • Apr 2010
    • 6

    #1

    CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

    I need a cap tester that can check caps in parallel and still soldered to the power supply board.

    Will this unit do that?

    What are the experiences with the CapAnalyzer 88A good or bad?

    Are there any other reliable cap testers brands that check caps in parallel while still soldered to the board? If so brand and model; where do I buy the tester for the best price?

    I have an LCD TV that I think the power supply is at fault but none of the capacitors look bulged or leaking, the tester should tell me once and for all if they need replacement.
  • Rippa_MD
    New Member
    • Apr 2010
    • 6

    #2
    Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

    Originally posted by Rippa_MD
    I need a cap tester that can check caps in parallel and still soldered to the power supply board.

    Will this unit do that?

    What are the experiences with the CapAnalyzer 88A good or bad?

    Are there any other reliable cap testers brands that check caps in parallel while still soldered to the board? If so brand and model; where do I buy the tester for the best price?

    I have an LCD TV that I think the power supply is at fault but none of the capacitors look bulged or leaking, the tester should tell me once and for all if they need replacement.

    anybody?? CapAnalyzer 88A Series II

    Comment

    • bluto
      Badcaps Veteran
      • Oct 2007
      • 557

      #3
      Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

      Yes I have a CapAnalyzer 88A. I am not an expert, so take that into account. That said, I think the tool does a decent job. It checks DC resistance first and beeps if there is a short. Then it checks ESR and the led bar graph on the side jumps up to the measured reading. The led that is illuminated indicates ESR ohms. Looking across on the chart next to the led, you can determine if the ESR is in the right range for the stated capacitance of the capacitor. Capacitors 220uf above should peg the bar graph led to the top.

      The in circuit testing seems to work well. I assume that if there are several caps in parallel, the tester is going to measure them as one. The only additional thing that I would like it to have is an actual numerical readout of ESR and capacitance.

      Comment

      • TrippKJ4BKD
        Member
        • Nov 2010
        • 19

        #4
        Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

        I also have the CapAnalyzer 88a. I like it alot. I am no expert and have only owned it for about 2 months. Have tested hundreds of caps and so far I think it is doing a good job. I like the fact that it discharges the cap before it tests it. I have tested a lot of caps that were 220uf and above that did not peg all the way to the top of the graph. Usally just 1 led below the top. Some times if I do not have a replacement I will go ahead and leave that cap in and usally the device will still work like it should.Maybe that cap is starting a decline or maybe that is normal for that cap. So far the devices that had caps that were that close and left in are all still working. Now if those devices fail in the near future do to those particullar caps than maybe I'll change my policy. Any how I can't conplain about the CapAnalyzer 88A.

        Comment

        • devid21
          Banned
          • Sep 2010
          • 82

          #5
          Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

          Originally posted by TrippKJ4BKD
          I also have the CapAnalyzer 88a. I like it alot. I am no expert and have only owned it for about 2 months. Have tested hundreds of caps and so far I think it is doing a good job. I like the fact that it discharges the cap before it tests it. I have tested a lot of caps that were 220uf and above that did not peg all the way to the top of the graph. Usally just 1 led below the top. Some times if I do not have a replacement I will go ahead and leave that cap in and usally the device will still work like it should.Maybe that cap is starting a decline or maybe that is normal for that cap. So far the devices that had caps that were that close and left in are all still working. Now if those devices fail in the near future do to those particullar caps than maybe I'll change my policy. Any how I can't conplain about the CapAnalyzer 88A.
          I have long been interested in this ESR meter.
          I am interested in more information.
          1.What´s his real lower limit of measurement?
          2.What is the voltage of the charget capacitor can withstand it?
          3.How it measures in circuit?
          I also have done with LED´s.
          I want to compare with their.
          Thank you for your reply.

          Comment

          • jotto
            Member
            • May 2012
            • 12
            • USA

            #6
            Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

            The best unit made is a LC 103 that was made by sencore. its no longer manufactured.

            I have used the capacitor wizard and the cap analyzer, both are good units. Nothing is perfect even the LC103 which is my main unit. There is also one is made by you that uses a pic chip. I have not made this unit but its good for someone startiing out.

            Its a good unit to have as test equipment that is quick and fast, but not 100 percent accurate. You will in time learn which will lead to false reading.

            Comment

            • insight
              New Member
              • Jun 2012
              • 1
              • USA

              #7
              Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

              There's a decent video about capacitor testing, featuring the CapAnalyzer 88A here.

              It's not specifically a review of the unit, but it goes in to some detail on how to use it and the owner's experience with it. It's worth watching, if you're considering buying one.

              Comment

              • Kiriakos GR
                Banned
                • May 2012
                • 940
                • Greece

                #8
                Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

                I am having the chance to explore the latest Agilent U1733C LCR for five days,
                probably my findings could look as interesting to some people.

                http://www.ittsb.eu/forum/index.php?topic=41.0

                Comment

                • rvmeush
                  New Member
                  • Feb 2013
                  • 1
                  • United States

                  #9
                  Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

                  I have been looking at getting a used 88A and would like to know how to tell the difference between the Series II model and the earlier model. From pictures that I have seen online I don't see any text on the meter that says Series II. Thanks.

                  Comment

                  • yz7myg
                    YU2MYG
                    • Feb 2007
                    • 18

                    #10
                    Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

                    Can a few pictures of the inside CapAnalyzer 88a.

                    Comment

                    • MicroMend
                      New Member
                      • Jun 2013
                      • 1
                      • UK

                      #11
                      Re: CapAnalyzer 88A EDS review?

                      
the EDS Cap Analyzer 88A is much less accurate and much more expensive than the peak ESR70,

                      
the peak electronics ESR70 is an awesome tester and can even find bad caps that the EDS 88A will identify as good

                      Also the EDS 88A will test up to 2,200 uF.
                      
the peak electronics ESR70 will test to 22,000 uF.

                      the 
peak ESR70 is better, cheaper and more accurate.

                      
I know I have both :-)

                      Comment

                      Related Topics

                      Collapse

                      • sam_sam_sam
                        FNIRSI HRM-10 Internal Resistance Detector AC Lead Acid Lithium Battery Tester Review on some testing of device
                        by sam_sam_sam
                        https://www.ebay.com/itm/405035016711

                        I got this device yesterday and did some testing on some tabbing and some incandescent light bulbs and it seems to work very well from what I can tell but how do I know how accurate the m-ohms section is what can I use to verify it accurately I also tested some li-ion battery cells and this seems to be fairly accurate because I have another tester and they seem to agree with each other

                        I also checked some capacitors with it that were brand new and seem to show about what I expected to see with my blue capacitor tester so I think it...
                        04-13-2025, 08:17 PM
                      • DoOm86
                        Doubts about: working laptop without a soldered ram/vga/battery
                        by DoOm86
                        I'm new to elettronic, so perhaps my question has no sense.
                        Can a laptop still work without one of the soldered ram?
                        I was wondering if a laptop (or any other device actually) can still works if removing a faulty soldered ram without soldering back a good replacement. Of course considering the mainboard has other ram chip perfectly functional.
                        I tried on a MacBook Air and also an Asus laptop and it seems no possible without a replacement. At least, not just removing the faulty one.
                        Sometimes for the seek of data recovery on a flash soldered drive on the mainboard,...
                        04-14-2023, 05:05 AM
                      • Lifeisfun
                        Trying to troubleshoot DDR4 SODIMM slot with slot tester
                        by Lifeisfun
                        Hi folks!
                        I have some kind of memory problem on Lenovo laptop. I was initially able to install windows after several tries since the laptop did freeze in middle of those attempts.
                        Eventually I discovered that it was related to moving the laptop.
                        Later on it even stopped booting unless I pressed around the memory slot. (no keyboard LEDs only power button responds)
                        If I remove the RAM I get the beeps that RAM is missing. Inserting the RAM there is silence and it will not boot most of the time. No picture.

                        I removed the board got one of those memory slot testers...
                        06-04-2025, 02:26 PM
                      • spleenharvester
                        Reverse engineering of 18650 4-channel tester
                        by spleenharvester
                        Hi friends

                        I have reverse engineered this tester, schematic is attached and is complete except for capacitor values. These testers annoyingly have no model number but they are the ones you find on the first page of just about any website if you type in "18650 4-channel tester". There is also a 2-channel variant and a newer 8-channel variant. They are very cheap (about £15) and can measure voltage, current, internal resistance and capacity. They have a multicolour display for all these statistics. They also have terminal blocks so that if you want to use a breakout board...
                        05-04-2025, 02:43 AM
                      • sam_sam_sam
                        Modification done to a EBC-A40L 5volts Battery Capacity Tester 40A for less noise when charging / discharging cycles
                        by sam_sam_sam
                        When I first turned this battery testing machine the fan for the switching power supply was a little bit noisy but once I recapped the switching power supply board it quiet down considerably then I put a temperature controlled fan that does the mosfets control board was really noisy but now that it is cooled with temperature controlled fan that sensor was moved from the fan to the heat sink so now that the fan is controlled this way the fan runs according to the temperature of the heat sink

                        This switching power supply was really fun to recap the quality of the board was very good...
                        02-25-2024, 08:55 PM
                      • Loading...
                      • No more items.
                      Working...