ESR meter reading implications

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bigbeark
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Jan 2010
    • 661
    • Canada

    #1

    ESR meter reading implications

    In the past, when measuring ESR on certain caps on certain boards I have seen the ESR reading trickle down to zero.

    Never thought much about it, but have been reading a bit on electronic theory lately (OK so it's Ohms Law). If there is no resistance, there is no current(?). So I'm thinking these zero readings indicate a problem. The capacitor is offering no resistance, so there is no flow.

    I have noticed that when I recap a board, the new capacitors will NEVER show zero ESR, lowest maybe .02.

    Also, in the past, I've been able to isolate bad caps with ESR readings higher than spec. I have observed that if the cap is 1500uf or more, that is it is not bulged or domed, the ESR reading is likely to be OK (or Zero).

    It seems to me that the 1000uf 8mm dia caps cause a lot more problems than the bigger ones. Their ESR can measure OK, but when I take them off
    the board and measure their capacitance, they are lower capacitance thn their label. Replacing these which are common around the PCI slots seems to restore many boards to life.

    So is the zero ESR reading a red-flag or a red-herring? Is the cap in fact "shorted"?

    I think there's more to using an ESR meter than just reading the numbers.
    Anyone care to offer some insights on using the meter?
  • Radio Fox
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Jan 2010
    • 281
    • UK

    #2
    Re: ESR meter reading implications

    Originally posted by bigbeark
    In the past, when measuring ESR on certain caps on certain boards I have seen the ESR reading trickle down to zero.

    Never thought much about it, but have been reading a bit on electronic theory lately (OK so it's Ohms Law). If there is no resistance, there is no current(?). So I'm thinking these zero readings indicate a problem. The capacitor is offering no resistance, so there is no flow.

    I have noticed that when I recap a board, the new capacitors will NEVER show zero ESR, lowest maybe .02.

    Also, in the past, I've been able to isolate bad caps with ESR readings higher than spec. I have observed that if the cap is 1500uf or more, that is it is not bulged or domed, the ESR reading is likely to be OK (or Zero).

    It seems to me that the 1000uf 8mm dia caps cause a lot more problems than the bigger ones. Their ESR can measure OK, but when I take them off
    the board and measure their capacitance, they are lower capacitance thn their label. Replacing these which are common around the PCI slots seems to restore many boards to life.

    So is the zero ESR reading a red-flag or a red-herring? Is the cap in fact "shorted"?

    I think there's more to using an ESR meter than just reading the numbers.
    Anyone care to offer some insights on using the meter?
    First, I think you have got your Ohm's Law muddled up. I=V/R, so the lower the resistance, the higher the current, not lower.

    Also from your post, you appear to be measuring some caps in circuit & others out of circuit. When you say that the reading trickles down to zero, is that only when measuring caps while still on the board? The only true ESR reading is when the cap is out of circuit. Have you ever measured zero on a capacitor out of circuit?

    Capacitors can change their value over time, but remember that a lot of electrolytics have quite a large tolerance, so make sure that a cap than can appear to be "wrong vale" is not just on the limit of it's tolerance.

    They can also go short circuit. This can be double checked using a regular resistance meter found on your multimeter.
    ________________________________________________

    Invisible airwaves crackle with life
    Bright antennae bristle with the energy
    ________________________________________________

    Comment

    • bigbeark
      Badcaps Veteran
      • Jan 2010
      • 661
      • Canada

      #3
      Re: ESR meter reading implications

      Originally posted by Radio Fox
      First, I think you have got your Ohm's Law muddled up. I=V/R, so the lower the resistance, the higher the current, not lower.

      Yes but if R is zero does current still flow?

      Also from your post, you appear to be measuring some caps in circuit & others out of circuit. When you say that the reading trickles down to zero, is that only when measuring caps while still on the board? The only true ESR reading is when the cap is out of circuit. Have you ever measured zero on a capacitor out of circuit?

      The zero rating is observed in-circuit on the old caps. When I replace all the caps with new ones and measure the replacement caps in-circuit I never see zero. I think the zero is indicating a tired group of caps. True, when I measure those caps out-of-circuit, I don't get zero.

      Capacitors can change their value over time, but remember that a lot of electrolytics have quite a large tolerance, so make sure that a cap than can appear to be "wrong vale" is not just on the limit of it's tolerance.

      Yes, that's my point. When I remove the old caps from the circuit, they meter OK in lots of cases, but collectively, on-board, they don't work. When I replace the whole lot, the board comes alive. I'm saying that the ESR meter is useful for finding fried caps, but has trouble zeroing in on an entire circuit of bagged-out caps.

      They can also go short circuit. This can be double checked using a regular resistance meter found on your multimeter.
      I will try that! I've been a little leery of using DMM in circuit for fear I burn something out with excess voltage.

      Comment

      • Radio Fox
        Badcaps Veteran
        • Jan 2010
        • 281
        • UK

        #4
        Re: ESR meter reading implications

        Yes but if R is zero does current still flow?
        Yes it does...lots of it! In theory, when R=0, I = infinity! In practice it is limited by how much current the circuit can supply. However, this just confuses things when talking about ESR as it's an imaginary (equivalent) resistance, in series with the capacitor, not a real one.

        The zero rating is observed in-circuit on the old caps. When I replace all the caps with new ones and measure the replacement caps in-circuit I never see zero. I think the zero is indicating a tired group of caps. True, when I measure those caps out-of-circuit, I don't get zero.
        Hmmm...I can't explain that. I was going to say that perhaps 1 out of a bank of caps had gone short circuit, which would explain the zero reading while in-circuit, but if they measured OK when taken out, then none of them could be short. And if the replacement caps worked OK & didn't show zero Ohms while in-circuit, then there isn't a short on the board. Strange.

        Yes, that's my point. When I remove the old caps from the circuit, they meter OK in lots of cases, but collectively, on-board, they don't work. When I replace the whole lot, the board comes alive. I'm saying that the ESR meter is useful for finding fried caps, but has trouble zeroing in on an entire circuit of bagged-out caps.
        That's the problem when using an ESR meter on caps that are connected in parallel on a circuit board. For example you could have a bank of 4 caps. 3 of them could have really low ESR, but the 4th might have sky high ESR. Because they are connected in parallel, the 3 good ones will mask the bad one & unless the bad one is showing some physical signs, then there is no way to know which one it is without taking them off the board.

        In my experience a cap that has changed it's value past it's tolerance usually shows a high ESR reading as well, although I don't know if that is always the case.

        I will try that! I've been a little leery of using DMM in circuit for fear I burn something out with excess voltage.
        I would remove any suspect caps first before testing them, although a DMM set to it's lowest Ohms range shouldn't do any harm to any other components on the circuit board (make sure the circuit board isn't powered of course, before doing any resistance measurements).
        Last edited by Radio Fox; 11-11-2010, 11:08 AM.
        ________________________________________________

        Invisible airwaves crackle with life
        Bright antennae bristle with the energy
        ________________________________________________

        Comment

        • tjohnson4
          New Member
          • Nov 2010
          • 4

          #5
          Re: ESR meter reading implications

          Actually, if R=0 then I is undefined. I wish I had a nickel for every time I've been corrected on that one. However, as R->0, I->infinity... if V is positive.

          I usually prefer I*R=V. Then I don't get anyone telling me that I divided by zero.

          Comment

          • PCBONEZ
            Grumpy Old Fart
            • Aug 2005
            • 10661
            • USA

            #6
            Re: ESR meter reading implications

            If R were ever actually =0 then V would also =0 because it would be the same point electrically.
            If V and R both =0 then so does I.

            How ya like them apples?
            .
            Last edited by PCBONEZ; 11-29-2010, 04:29 AM.
            Mann-Made Global Warming.
            - We should be more concerned about the Intellectual Climate.

            -
            Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind.

            - Dr Seuss
            -
            You can teach a man to fish and feed him for life, but if he can't handle sushi you must also teach him to cook.
            -

            Comment

            Related Topics

            Collapse

            • novice1
              Acer Aspire E5-574G - Not Powering On
              by novice1
              Laptop name Acer Aspire E5-574G. Processor = i7-6500u. GPU = NVIDIA GEFORCE 940M. Motherboard Model = DA0ZRWMB6G0

              This laptop was not powering on at all so I started investigating. The blue light would come on for a second, and then disappear. Fan would sometimes turn on for a second and then shut off immediately, and at other times would not turn on at all.

              To start with, about 3 months ago I had no clue about soldering, motherboard schematics, board view, and then I stumbled about this forum and other stuff online. I have never done any of those before. But to ask...
              11-03-2023, 05:53 PM
            • lezsimply
              Low resistance reading on 3v line, Asus Prime H310M-A R2.0 desktop motherboard
              by lezsimply
              Hello Everyone and Good Day,

              I've got an issue with this desktop motherboard. It does not power on, Asus Prime H310M-A R2.0. I tested 33ohms reading on 3v line on the ATX connector. It beeps on continuity mode. I tried injecting voltage from 0.9v at 1.5amps and no current being drawn. I raised the voltage to 3v @ 4amps and now I only get 22mA on current. I checked with thermal camera and there is no part heating up. I'm afraid of going further the safe voltage. What could possibly causing the line to be shorted. 5vsb has no short. I get 0.9v on positive pin of power switch. There's...
              11-22-2024, 03:14 AM
            • karoliens
              820-01700 PPVCC_S0_CPU normal resistance to ground/diode reading?
              by karoliens
              I am working on this board that has some water damage though not around this rail but I measured it anyway to rule out that CPU is not fried.
              Resistance to ground on PPVCC_S0_CPU rail is 2Ohm and in diode mode it shows 0V.
              What is the normal reading on that rail?
              TIA
              09-11-2022, 12:55 PM
            • Takeatry
              Yet another Samsung QLED Boot Loop
              by Takeatry
              Samsung QLED QN50Q — purchased 2022 started experiencing a delay in the picture coming on in the morning less than 2 years later. Did not know the term boot loop at that time. As the loop delay ran into a few minutes did all the recommended troubleshooting, soft and hard reset, changing cables and outlet locations, no help. As the delay increased contacted Samsung tech group and allow them remote access the tv. Tech was moving too fast to see exactly what he was doing but this ultimately it was also no help. Lived with the delay until it stretched out over 6 hours. Pulled of off the back cover...
              10-04-2024, 02:57 PM
            • sam_sam_sam
              AE20218 Milliohm Meter Kit, 0.1 Milliohm Resolution, Four Wire Measurements bought one
              by sam_sam_sam
              I have been in need of a mega ohm meter for a while but just could not make up my mind to which one I want to buy and this one has a couple of things going for it can also be used on a computer to display a resistance graph plus it is a kit that you put together supposedly the only parts installed are the surface mount components

              I will probably make a rechargeable battery pack for so it can be used as a portable device and anywhere

              I kind a wish that it had a higher resistance value higher than 240 ohms at 10 milliamperes on high range but it is what it it
              On the...
              03-15-2025, 05:10 PM
            • Loading...
            • No more items.
            Working...