Instead of bad caps for this post, bad HDDs instead ;)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • RJARRRPCGP
    Badcaps Legend
    • Jul 2004
    • 6301
    • USA

    #1

    Instead of bad caps for this post, bad HDDs instead ;)

    Well, I went to a place in Windsor, Vermont that deals with used PC parts, both good and bad, thus I went to test some HDDs. Sad, but true, saw a good amount of bad Western Digital HDDs.

    I noticed that when Western Digital HDDs fail, the common symptom is the failure of accessing most of the drive, only a quarter of the HDD is readable and writable! Then if and when I attempt to access beyond the quarter of the HDD space, bad sectors are reported then the OS locks up usally with a click of death.

    Saw a Caviar WD300BB 30 GB UDMA 100 7,200 RPM HDD that was made in 2002. To my major disappointment, the HDD, even when no older than 2002 when powered, immediately gave me a SMART error, the HDD literally repeatedly emitted a bleeping sound accompanied by me feeling the HDD pulsing with each bleep sound.

    I also saw a 1 GB version that out of the blue was inaccessable beyond 238 MB then if any program attempted to access beyond 238 MB of the HDD, the utility would lock up and give me a click of death. When I tried Spin Rite, even that failed.


    Has anyone been seeing a rash of bad HDDs lately? (excluding the IBM Deskstar HDDs that some people are having major problems with)
    ASRock B550 PG Velocita

    Ryzen 9 "Vermeer" 5900X

    32 GB G.Skill RipJaws V F4-3200C16D-32GVR

    Arc A770 16 GB

    eVGA Supernova G3 750W

    Western Digital Black SN850 1TB NVMe SSD

    Alienware AW3423DWF OLED




    "¡Me encanta "Me Encanta o Enlistarlo con Hilary Farr!" -Mí mismo

    "There's nothing more unattractive than a chick smoking a cigarette" -Topcat

    "Today's lesson in pissivity comes in the form of a ziplock baggie full of GPU extension brackets & hardware that for the last ~3 years have been on my bench, always in my way, getting moved around constantly....and yesterday I found myself in need of them....and the bastards are now nowhere to be found! Motherfracker!!" -Topcat

    "did I see a chair fly? I think I did! Time for popcorn!" -ratdude747
  • willawake
    Super Modulator
    • Nov 2003
    • 8457
    • Greece

    #2
    I have had mixed experiences. My friend at the computer shop told me that they get more WD returned with failure than Seagate but he also advised that they sell more WD.

    In the office we used to have quantum fireballs. I still have 3 running today after years. Others failed dissapointingly. I have seen a maxtor slow down to an incredibly slow speed so it was replaced. I have never seen that with other HDDs. Then we moved to WD. Same mixed experience as with the quantums. Some still running great after 3 years. But lately i have switched to Seagate because :

    1. I had two WD hard disks which did not pass the dlgdiag (too many errors) as new.
    2. WD hard disks failed in the mailserver after 1 year and then the next and next after 2 months.
    3. I had a WD develop an abnormal sound early.
    4. I had a WD which made a high pitched sound from new but works fine.
    3. Seagate come in nice protective plastic cases.
    4. I feel like a change.

    I have a new seagate yet to be installed which gives the impression it is vibrating excessively (still have to decide what to do about that).

    In conclusion, I think that many products including hard disks are becoming too cheap and that can only mean worse quality. It is a PIA when an office hdd fails, takes me a day to do the setup again. I prefer to reinstall windows with newer versions of all software and drivers than keep a ghost of each computer. i always scan every new hdd with the manufacturers utility before installing. I know that dlgdiag is an honest utility, not sure about the seatools though.

    One thing i would never buy is second hand hard disks though.
    capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

    Comment

    • RJARRRPCGP
      Badcaps Legend
      • Jul 2004
      • 6301
      • USA

      #3
      I'm thinking about getting a Seagate HDD, because of the 8.5 ms seek time.

      Should be faster with almost everything.


      But unfortunately at the used computer part place in Windsor, Vermont, when I saw a Seagate 10 GB UDMA 100 HDD which also has the low 8.5 ms latency, it was bad, some bad sectors and was slow. When I decided to copy a couple of large files from one folder on the HDD to the Windows desktop, it was slower than it was supposed to be and sounded like a jackhammer. LOL.

      Thus I was required to take that HDD back and say that it's bad.

      Was getting unlucky at that place so far.
      ASRock B550 PG Velocita

      Ryzen 9 "Vermeer" 5900X

      32 GB G.Skill RipJaws V F4-3200C16D-32GVR

      Arc A770 16 GB

      eVGA Supernova G3 750W

      Western Digital Black SN850 1TB NVMe SSD

      Alienware AW3423DWF OLED




      "¡Me encanta "Me Encanta o Enlistarlo con Hilary Farr!" -Mí mismo

      "There's nothing more unattractive than a chick smoking a cigarette" -Topcat

      "Today's lesson in pissivity comes in the form of a ziplock baggie full of GPU extension brackets & hardware that for the last ~3 years have been on my bench, always in my way, getting moved around constantly....and yesterday I found myself in need of them....and the bastards are now nowhere to be found! Motherfracker!!" -Topcat

      "did I see a chair fly? I think I did! Time for popcorn!" -ratdude747

      Comment

      • willawake
        Super Modulator
        • Nov 2003
        • 8457
        • Greece

        #4
        i forgot to say that i have worse experience with the newer black WD caviar se hard disks although i have some good ones.

        forget about used hdds. used is good for anything but hdds.

        do you use the manufacturers utility to write zeros on the drives? sometimes revives a previously bad hdd. but any pings and other crappy sounds, forget about it. no sense putting data on it.

        maybe find some mobos at that place, recap them and sell em and then buy a new drive.

        i have a ibm deathstar working fine. i was lucky.
        capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

        Comment

        • RJARRRPCGP
          Badcaps Legend
          • Jul 2004
          • 6301
          • USA

          #5
          Originally posted by willawake
          i forgot to say that i have worse experience with the newer black WD caviar se hard disks although i have some good ones.

          forget about used hdds. used is good for anything but hdds.

          do you use the manufacturers utility to write zeros on the drives? sometimes revives a previously bad hdd. but any pings and other crappy sounds, forget about it. no sense putting data on it.

          maybe find some mobos at that place, recap them and sell em and then buy a new drive.

          i have a ibm deathstar working fine. i was lucky.
          Yep, I did with the Western Digital HDDs, but no change.

          Also, I do have some good used HDDs, just that at the place I have been at, hasn't been weeding out all of the bad HDDs. I actually go there to test HDDs and if no errors and abnormal sounds, I then say that they're fine.

          I brought this topic up, because I saw HDDs that were new and failed in less than 3 years. Failed probably before the end of the warranty.
          ASRock B550 PG Velocita

          Ryzen 9 "Vermeer" 5900X

          32 GB G.Skill RipJaws V F4-3200C16D-32GVR

          Arc A770 16 GB

          eVGA Supernova G3 750W

          Western Digital Black SN850 1TB NVMe SSD

          Alienware AW3423DWF OLED




          "¡Me encanta "Me Encanta o Enlistarlo con Hilary Farr!" -Mí mismo

          "There's nothing more unattractive than a chick smoking a cigarette" -Topcat

          "Today's lesson in pissivity comes in the form of a ziplock baggie full of GPU extension brackets & hardware that for the last ~3 years have been on my bench, always in my way, getting moved around constantly....and yesterday I found myself in need of them....and the bastards are now nowhere to be found! Motherfracker!!" -Topcat

          "did I see a chair fly? I think I did! Time for popcorn!" -ratdude747

          Comment

          • RoadKill
            Member
            • Jun 2004
            • 49

            #6
            In Seagate I trust.

            Comment

            • Fatal0E
              Badcaps Veteran
              • Jan 2004
              • 252

              #7
              Sell
              Maxtor---very high failure rate within first 2 years
              WD---recently a somewhat concerning failure rate within 2 months
              Samsung----do these things actually fail? sent like 2 back in last 3 years
              Hitachi----Never sent one back
              Seagate---Since barracude IV only sent 1 7200.7 back


              move about 60 drives per week, random makes, havent stocked maxtor in about 3 months though.

              Comment

              • RJARRRPCGP
                Badcaps Legend
                • Jul 2004
                • 6301
                • USA

                #8
                Both Maxtor HDDs that I purchased are running in my PC are fine.


                Just be wary of any bad sectors. Like the bulging with capacitors, bad sectors are the common first symptom of HDD failure.
                ASRock B550 PG Velocita

                Ryzen 9 "Vermeer" 5900X

                32 GB G.Skill RipJaws V F4-3200C16D-32GVR

                Arc A770 16 GB

                eVGA Supernova G3 750W

                Western Digital Black SN850 1TB NVMe SSD

                Alienware AW3423DWF OLED




                "¡Me encanta "Me Encanta o Enlistarlo con Hilary Farr!" -Mí mismo

                "There's nothing more unattractive than a chick smoking a cigarette" -Topcat

                "Today's lesson in pissivity comes in the form of a ziplock baggie full of GPU extension brackets & hardware that for the last ~3 years have been on my bench, always in my way, getting moved around constantly....and yesterday I found myself in need of them....and the bastards are now nowhere to be found! Motherfracker!!" -Topcat

                "did I see a chair fly? I think I did! Time for popcorn!" -ratdude747

                Comment

                • bushytails
                  Moderator
                  • Dec 2004
                  • 217

                  #9
                  Quantum drives are the only ones I've ever had fail, aside from one WD... Every quantum I've owned, save for the one I just put into a computer 3 days ago, has failed in the same way... sitction on the main bearings. At one point I had THREE quantum drives, all of different models, that took a sharp twist to get the drives to spin up on a cold morning...

                  --Randy

                  Comment

                  • willawake
                    Super Modulator
                    • Nov 2003
                    • 8457
                    • Greece

                    #10
                    Samsung----do these things actually fail? sent like 2 back in last 3 years
                    hmmm. I have heard they are very quiet too. i will check these out. Samsung has very good quality control.

                    Hitachi----Never sent one back
                    hitachi bought IBM HDD division a few years back. maybe the quality control is better now. IBMs used to be made by http://www.excelstor.com/ in China. I think they still make at least some of the models. Excelstor also make a few models under their own brand. I have seen these in the shops here.

                    Maxtor---very high failure rate within first 2 years
                    Maxtor Atlas Ultra320 scsi drives are in many servers HP, Dell etc. I hope they dont have the same failure rate (have 4 in my HP)
                    capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

                    Comment

                    • RoadKill
                      Member
                      • Jun 2004
                      • 49

                      #11
                      I don't know about high end Maxtors, but I can tell you, if you ever come across a slimline 3.5" maxtor, they are the work of Satan, they will fail as soon as any bad cap

                      Comment

                      • RJARRRPCGP
                        Badcaps Legend
                        • Jul 2004
                        • 6301
                        • USA

                        #12
                        Originally posted by RoadKill
                        I don't know about high end Maxtors, but I can tell you, if you ever come across a slimline 3.5" maxtor, they are the work of Satan, they will fail as soon as any bad cap
                        Thanks for the heads up, but a slimline 3.5" HDD I have seems to be the best HDD performance wise I would ever own so far. Just have to download the Maxtor HDD diagnostic utility, if able to. The HDD seems OK, but it's only 1 year old, was manufactured on March 29, 2003 according to the data print.

                        It didn't make any abnormal sounds that I can distinguish and is the quitest HDD I have had.

                        It even appears to perform better than my Maxtor 80 GB UDMA 100 5,400 RPM HDD. HD Tach showed it basically comparing right with the SATA HDDs, get around 50 MB/s for the sustained transfer rate!
                        ASRock B550 PG Velocita

                        Ryzen 9 "Vermeer" 5900X

                        32 GB G.Skill RipJaws V F4-3200C16D-32GVR

                        Arc A770 16 GB

                        eVGA Supernova G3 750W

                        Western Digital Black SN850 1TB NVMe SSD

                        Alienware AW3423DWF OLED




                        "¡Me encanta "Me Encanta o Enlistarlo con Hilary Farr!" -Mí mismo

                        "There's nothing more unattractive than a chick smoking a cigarette" -Topcat

                        "Today's lesson in pissivity comes in the form of a ziplock baggie full of GPU extension brackets & hardware that for the last ~3 years have been on my bench, always in my way, getting moved around constantly....and yesterday I found myself in need of them....and the bastards are now nowhere to be found! Motherfracker!!" -Topcat

                        "did I see a chair fly? I think I did! Time for popcorn!" -ratdude747

                        Comment

                        • RoadKill
                          Member
                          • Jun 2004
                          • 49

                          #13
                          No disrespect to your experience, but I have personally seen slimline 3.5" Maxtor HDDs (40GB ones) fail en masse, and it happened to my primary system, as well as many Dells at work.

                          Comment

                          • RJARRRPCGP
                            Badcaps Legend
                            • Jul 2004
                            • 6301
                            • USA

                            #14
                            Well, with that HDD, Powermax passed. 8) No bad sectors at all when I formatted it once already.

                            To be honest with you, I had the worst luck with Western Digital HDDs. The HDDs I find bad sectors with are usually Western Digital HDDs.

                            So far, probably until I go back to that place in Windsor, Vermont, I had only saw one bad Maxtor HDD.

                            The symptoms were different:

                            1. When installing Windows 98 SE, the Windows 98 SE installation process failed with a cab file decoding error.

                            2. Suddenly, but probably not until at least a week later, the BIOS failed to even detect the HDD at all!!!
                            Then, when I hooked it up to another PC, the BIOS ended up hanging and then displayed the message stating that the HDD failed to respond or that a C: drive error occured.


                            That was with a Maxtor 1 GB HDD. All of the Maxtor HDDs I purchased, including the 13 GB 7,200 RPM HDD from November, 1999 are still usable and still haven't even saw one bad sector so far!
                            ASRock B550 PG Velocita

                            Ryzen 9 "Vermeer" 5900X

                            32 GB G.Skill RipJaws V F4-3200C16D-32GVR

                            Arc A770 16 GB

                            eVGA Supernova G3 750W

                            Western Digital Black SN850 1TB NVMe SSD

                            Alienware AW3423DWF OLED




                            "¡Me encanta "Me Encanta o Enlistarlo con Hilary Farr!" -Mí mismo

                            "There's nothing more unattractive than a chick smoking a cigarette" -Topcat

                            "Today's lesson in pissivity comes in the form of a ziplock baggie full of GPU extension brackets & hardware that for the last ~3 years have been on my bench, always in my way, getting moved around constantly....and yesterday I found myself in need of them....and the bastards are now nowhere to be found! Motherfracker!!" -Topcat

                            "did I see a chair fly? I think I did! Time for popcorn!" -ratdude747

                            Comment

                            • Preowner
                              Member
                              • Mar 2005
                              • 13

                              #15
                              I watched maxtor and WD go from most popular to pos. Atleast thats how it was in my area.

                              I always dispised maxtor because for some reason they went for years w/o labeling the drive size.

                              Seagate, I hear way back owning one was a fate worse than the owning several clicking deskstars.

                              Being disgusted with the current default cheap drive makers I looked elsewhere. I now own a Samsung 120Gb Sata drive. Only working on a few months, but I hear no motor whine, and head movement noise is only noticeable because the vibration is amplified by my desk. I got it for less than $70 new online.

                              Comment

                              • willawake
                                Super Modulator
                                • Nov 2003
                                • 8457
                                • Greece

                                #16
                                capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

                                Comment

                                • sulbert
                                  Senior Member
                                  • Dec 2004
                                  • 59

                                  #17
                                  Nobody mentioned Fujitsu hard drives here? Especially the MPG series have remarkable failure rates. My last Fujitsu experience was a MPF3102AT which started making weird things and did not pass the comprehensive test of Fujitsu Diagnostic Tool.
                                  Last edited by sulbert; 03-15-2005, 06:28 AM. Reason: typos

                                  Comment

                                  • Lance Thornton
                                    Senior Member
                                    • Jan 2005
                                    • 84

                                    #18
                                    I work as a subcontractor for the US Government. The PC Admin and I are good friends and have lunches together when possible. He recently told me about 3 Maxtor Diamondmax SATA drives failing within weeks of each other. All out of Dells and currently, he is waiting for an adapter to try to recover the data. One big problem is that one harddrive is his, and it has the data recovery software on it! If memory serves, Seagate has changed to a 5 year warranty, so maybe they know something about their product that we don't yet.

                                    Comment

                                    Related Topics

                                    Collapse

                                    • Document Archive
                                      HP EliteDesk 800 G3 + ProDisplay P240va + Seagate Game Drive for Xbox 2TB Green EliteDesk 800 i5-7500 Specification for Upgrade or Repair
                                      by Document Archive
                                      This specification for the HP EliteDesk 800 G3 + ProDisplay P240va + Seagate Game Drive for Xbox 2TB Green can be useful for upgrading or repairing a desktop PC that is not working. As a community we are working through our specifications to add valuable data like the EliteDesk 800 G3 + ProDisplay P240va + Seagate Game Drive for Xbox 2TB Green boardview and EliteDesk 800 G3 + ProDisplay P240va + Seagate Game Drive for Xbox 2TB Green schematic. Our users have donated over 1 million documents which are being added to the site. This page will be updated soon with additional information. Alternatively...
                                      09-12-2024, 02:00 PM
                                    • Document Archive
                                      HP ProBook 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook 400 Specification for Upgrade or Repair
                                      by Document Archive
                                      This specification for the HP ProBook 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook can be useful for upgrading or repairing a laptop that is not working. As a community we are working through our specifications to add valuable data like the 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB boardview and 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB schematic. Our users have donated over 1 million documents which are being added to the site. This page will be updated soon with additional information. Alternatively you can request additional help from our users directly on the relevant badcaps forum. Please note that we offer no warranties...
                                      09-06-2024, 08:10 PM
                                    • Document Archive
                                      HP ProBook 450 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook 400 Specification for Upgrade or Repair
                                      by Document Archive
                                      This specification for the HP ProBook 450 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook can be useful for upgrading or repairing a laptop that is not working. As a community we are working through our specifications to add valuable data like the 450 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB boardview and 450 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB schematic. Our users have donated over 1 million documents which are being added to the site. This page will be updated soon with additional information. Alternatively you can request additional help from our users directly on the relevant badcaps forum. Please note that we offer no warranties...
                                      09-06-2024, 08:10 PM
                                    • Document Archive
                                      HP ProBook 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook 400 Specification for Upgrade or Repair
                                      by Document Archive
                                      This specification for the HP ProBook 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook can be useful for upgrading or repairing a laptop that is not working. As a community we are working through our specifications to add valuable data like the 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB boardview and 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB schematic. Our users have donated over 1 million documents which are being added to the site. This page will be updated soon with additional information. Alternatively you can request additional help from our users directly on the relevant badcaps forum. Please note that we offer no warranties...
                                      09-06-2024, 08:10 PM
                                    • Document Archive
                                      HP ProBook 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook 400 Specification for Upgrade or Repair
                                      by Document Archive
                                      This specification for the HP ProBook 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB Notebook can be useful for upgrading or repairing a laptop that is not working. As a community we are working through our specifications to add valuable data like the 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB boardview and 430 G7 + Seagate Expansion 1TB schematic. Our users have donated over 1 million documents which are being added to the site. This page will be updated soon with additional information. Alternatively you can request additional help from our users directly on the relevant badcaps forum. Please note that we offer no warranties...
                                      09-06-2024, 08:10 PM
                                    • Loading...
                                    • No more items.
                                    Working...