Rationale for "lamp error" detection

Collapse
X
Collapse
+ More Options
Posts
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Curious.George
    Badcaps Legend
    • Nov 2011
    • 2305
    • Unknown

    #1

    Rationale for "lamp error" detection

    Hi,

    This one is just for curiosity's sake...

    Subject makes it sound silly -- why detect a CCFL failure as it should be obvious to the user (viewer)?

    I was working on an Aquos LC20B2UA (an ancient set) and was surprised to see all the components (components == $$) dedicated to monitoring lamp current! Each of the 10 lamps are monitored! Though only a single "error" signal is reported to the controller (i.e., it can't tell if 1 lamp or 10 lamps are at fault).

    [It looks like the circuitry detects an open tube or a missing excitation voltage. I'll have to look at it more closely tomorrow...]

    Surely, this is overkill?

    The set has two inverter boards: one drives 6 lamps (three dual converters) while the other drives 4 lamps (two converters). Each board is individually fused. I.e., a fuse blows and you lose 4 or 6 lamps. A converter blows and you lose two lamps. A transformer/tube opens and you lose one lamp. All of these situations should be visible to the user, right? (I should try this...)

    N.B. The set has no blink codes! Lamp errors are counted and displayed in the service menu. Each shuts down the set. The fifth such error causes the controller to inhibit the set from being powered up, thereafter. Remember, there are no blink codes so the user just sees a dead set in this case!

    This suggests the reason for monitoring each lamp has to do with a type of error that can plague a single tube (thus requiring you to monitor all of them) that the user would not "notice" while watching the set.

    Furthermore, shutting down the set suggests that this error would be a safety issue -- especially in light of preventing it from powering up after five such errors!

    So, my question: what is the nature of this "failure" that would merit adding these components (i.e., to monitor each and every lamp) -- yet not also warrant reporting the error to the user (blink code)?

    Thanks!
  • tom66
    EVs Rule
    • Apr 2011
    • 32560
    • UK

    #2
    Re: Rationale for "lamp error" detection

    If you have an open bulb, you're no longer loading a transformer. This means its output can increase from the nominal 700V to 5~10 times that, which can damage the transformer, burn stuff, arc to the frame and make an unpleasant smell. Similar thing goes for short circuit failures. They want to minimise the risk of fires.

    As for no blink code, it's possible that Sharp didn't think of doing that until their later models.
    Please do not PM me with questions! Questions via PM will not be answered. Post on the forums instead!
    For service manual, schematic, boardview (board view), datasheet, cad - use our search.

    Comment

    • Curious.George
      Badcaps Legend
      • Nov 2011
      • 2305
      • Unknown

      #3
      Re: Rationale for "lamp error" detection

      Originally posted by tom66
      If you have an open bulb, you're no longer loading a transformer. This means its output can increase from the nominal 700V to 5~10 times that, which can damage the transformer, burn stuff, arc to the frame and make an unpleasant smell.
      Ah! I hadn't considered the transformers would have such a high output impedance! I'll have to drag out a HV probe and see what things look like unloaded...

      Originally posted by tom66
      Similar thing goes for short circuit failures. They want to minimise the risk of fires.
      Presumably, short is reflected back to blowing the fuse on the converter's primary?

      Bottom line: lamp error covers anything wrong with any of the lamps and/or related circuitry (e.g., blown fuses, converters, missing primary supply, open lamp, shorted output, etc.).

      The fact that sets don't shut down after a single error suggests the detection isn't reliable (the controller could always shutdown a converter, verify the error goes away, then restart the converter to see if it is a "persistent" condition).

      Thanks!

      Comment

      • tom66
        EVs Rule
        • Apr 2011
        • 32560
        • UK

        #4
        Re: Rationale for "lamp error" detection

        Continuously attempting to light the backlight is a recipe for fire/smoke. You don't want that.
        http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencete...mit-smoke.html
        Please do not PM me with questions! Questions via PM will not be answered. Post on the forums instead!
        For service manual, schematic, boardview (board view), datasheet, cad - use our search.

        Comment

        • Curious.George
          Badcaps Legend
          • Nov 2011
          • 2305
          • Unknown

          #5
          Re: Rationale for "lamp error" detection

          Originally posted by tom66
          Continuously attempting to light the backlight is a recipe for fire/smoke. You don't want that.
          http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencete...mit-smoke.html
          The user turning the set on again effectively tries to relight the backlights. The point of my comment was, why give the set 5 errors before locking up? I.e., if the detection circuitry was effective/robust, the first detected error should be enough to cause the set to refuse to start (why give the user 4 more tries?)

          If the error is signaled due to an inverter/fuse failure, then the second (third, fourth, and fifth) attempts will also fail.

          If the error is signaled by an "open" lamp, the same should apply.

          The only way for the error to appear and then disappear (without an intervening service call) is if the failure is intermittent or the detection means are inconclusive.

          I just don't understand why "once isn't enough". Like replacing a fuse five times before looking to see why it's blowing in the first place!

          Comment

          • tom66
            EVs Rule
            • Apr 2011
            • 32560
            • UK

            #6
            Re: Rationale for "lamp error" detection

            Because they said so. Do you want a better answer? I doubt there is one.
            They probably did a failure analysis and said, "in the average lifetime of the TV we expect three random failures to occur, so allow up to five to limit harm."

            Or, perhaps it's related to five errors of any type, and some programmer neglected to change it. And it's stuck. The five error buffer is very useful on these sets that's for sure.
            Please do not PM me with questions! Questions via PM will not be answered. Post on the forums instead!
            For service manual, schematic, boardview (board view), datasheet, cad - use our search.

            Comment

            Related Topics

            Collapse

            • vestaviascott
              Epson 5040UB Projector No Lamp Strike Stuck in Startup - Blinking Status/Lamp Lights
              by vestaviascott
              Hoping someone here can put me on the right track. I'm trying to troubleshoot/flowchart the "internal projector error" on my newly acquired Facebook Marketplace bought Epson 5040UB projector (3LED, not DLP). Owner said it needed new lamp, actually error code blink pattern indicates "Internal Projector Error, call Epson support". Unit is out of warranty as of 8/19

              Here's what happens:

              1) Power on
              2) Blue power indicator lights and the lens cover motor opens the lens cover, light fan noise heard
              3) Blue status light flashes for appx 4 minutes...
              07-29-2020, 06:08 AM
            • AJ847.63e
              BenQ TH681 Originally overheating now wont fire the lamp - Colour wheel not starting
              by AJ847.63e
              Hi All.

              Does anyone have any reference materials or something I can use to try troubleshooting a BenQ TH681? Google unfortunately has turned up zip. I did find a service manual for a W series BenQ but that is pretty much useless, it's more a glorified user manual. A list of voltages would be great as I suspect my mainboard is faulty, the colour wheel voltage is not dipping like it should.

              The one I am troubleshooting now was originally overheating after a lamp replacement. It originally would take 2 minutes or so for it to shut off and blink the temp and lamp lights...
              09-18-2023, 06:42 PM
            • khelane
              test active pfc power with lamp test
              by khelane
              Hello
              I have a big problem and that is that in some cases when repairing active pfc power supplies I cannot work with a test lamp. I can only get help with 5 volts standby and for starting and starting I have to work without a lamp and this way there is a possibility of parts exploding and other parts being added.
              Sometimes with a multimeter test the problems can be reduced to some extent, but I had several cases that had to be tested on and online and recently two varistors exploded. They had terrible resistance because the power supplies were over 800 watts.
              Is there a way...
              06-03-2025, 01:00 AM
            • FALKLAN
              Running Line Voltage and Integrating LED Pods - Automotive
              by FALKLAN
              Howdy everyone! I hope all is well where ever you are!

              I'm attempting to integrate a couple of LED pods into an automotive reverse lamp circuit. The problem being, while the vehicle is running there is a 8.5v current present on the reverse lamp power wire. Needless to say is that all LED pods and lights dimly illuminate while the 8.5v is present, so the LEDs are always powered on while the vehicle is running. When the vehicle is shifted into reverse, the voltage changes to 12 volts.

              I am uncertain how to convert this line into a switched 12v output line for the LED pods....
              02-05-2025, 12:30 AM
            • mikey5791
              Help on Samsung Syncmaster T220 dead ccfl lamp
              by mikey5791
              Hi,

              This monitor previously is my main working monitor which i have been using for 8~9 years. Yesterday, when i switched on my pc from fresh to power on, the monitor is just black no display. I started dismantle to look inside the monitor power board but nothing looks suspicious or burnt. So i took my external ccfl inverter to try to power the monitor ccfl lamps which consisted of 2 lamps on upper part and 2 lamps on the lower part.

              Found out the upper ccfl lamp which is supposed to connect to cn304 on the power board did not light up. Then i installed a used working...
              10-18-2020, 03:17 AM
            • Loading...
            • No more items.
            Working...