System Specs:
Gigabyte Bad Caps - misdiagnosis?
<lead-in>
+/- 3 weeks ago, my system started displaying erratic behavior. I had just swithced from Ubuntu to Debian and chalked up the freezing to my Ubuntu-tard inexperience with Debian. Finally, I started looking into hardware causes. Reseating ram seemed to solve the problem - only temporarily. Problems became more erratic with sudden, complete shutdowns. System able to post, boot into OS but short lived (+/- 5 minutes) finally to where pushing the power button multiple times was the only way to get the system turned on. As if, it would only start after caps/electronics charged up (for lack of better understanding how to describe it)
Initially, noticed two bulged caps near the cpu, one clearly vented.
I pounded google trying to diagnose/confirm my suspicion it was the mobo alone. Removing GPU, ram, and power to mobo. The whistle/noise remained until I took power from the mobo.. Did put my ear next to PSU and could hear no sound. Thought this confirmed my diagnosis... but now, after more reading, I'm no longer convinced.
Now that I have a replacement mobo enroute, I begin cleaning up the box.
</lead-in>
<PSU specific>
Pulled PSU to clean it. After cleaning, I plugged it in, and hear a whistle (maybe a hum) from it, GREAT! Research suggest it too could be bad caps or a transformer hum. Try using a straw to zone into the culprit but not sure of the result. It [the sound] appears to be coming from between the two heat sinks. There's two ceramic caps (blue in color), two Electrolytic Capacitors (black), a transformer and many smaller electronic components (resistors, etc) in the area. BTW, no caps appear to be swollen, bulged tops or electrolyte leakeage (top or bottom)
Next, I checked the voltage output of the PSU. 3.3V (3.7V measured) and 5V (5.4V measured). 12V +&- are slightly lower @ 11.78V. Checked voltage with power on jumped and a small case fan plugged in.
With no load on the PSU, power on not jumped, the sound is what might be described as a leaking cap (air escaping). It may be psychosomatic and only be a hum though *shruggs*. If I turn the switch off, the sound goes up in tone/frequency steadily and stops (1-3 seconds) abruptly.
With the power on circuit jumped and an old case fan plugged in, the sound is still there but it's different. In fact, it acts like a wave; meaning, the tone/frequency goes up and down (think wave form on an oscope). I guess I didn't hear this before cause of the cpu, hdd and case fans. Then again, maybe it's a recent thing and is the reason my system became unstable... eventually, unusable. Too, perhaps this is from almost zero load on the PSU, comparatively, to what is there when the system is together (mobo, ram, gpu, 3 hdd's, dvd drive, mouse, keyboard).
</PSU specific>
<Questions>
Did I give enough info to help diagnose the situation?
Does it appear that blaming the motherboard was premature or not, in whole, correct?
Is the sound now heard from the PSU, normal, for such a low-grade PSU? (just read the review on it from hardware secrets)
</Questions>
Final thoughts:
Thanks if you've read this far and/or have time to assist!
Any suggestions, recommendations, request for specific info, or chastisement; will be welcome.
~Steve
PS. Lucky for me, a fellow LUG member let me borrom an old emachine with a single core 64bit and 256mb ram. We did upgrade the ram for him by adding a 1GB stick from a local computer repair shop. Have much more appreciation for my old, pre-death-bed system now!
Thermaltake TR2-430NP
Gigabyte GA-M61P-S3
Athlon 64 X2 4200+ Windsor
EVGA GeForce 8600 GTS 512MB PCIe x16
OCZ DDR2 1066 4GB Kit (2x2GB)
2x 250GB Seagate HDD
1x 500GB Seagate HDD
1x Liteon 22x DVD RW
Gigabyte GA-M61P-S3
Athlon 64 X2 4200+ Windsor
EVGA GeForce 8600 GTS 512MB PCIe x16
OCZ DDR2 1066 4GB Kit (2x2GB)
2x 250GB Seagate HDD
1x 500GB Seagate HDD
1x Liteon 22x DVD RW
<lead-in>
+/- 3 weeks ago, my system started displaying erratic behavior. I had just swithced from Ubuntu to Debian and chalked up the freezing to my Ubuntu-tard inexperience with Debian. Finally, I started looking into hardware causes. Reseating ram seemed to solve the problem - only temporarily. Problems became more erratic with sudden, complete shutdowns. System able to post, boot into OS but short lived (+/- 5 minutes) finally to where pushing the power button multiple times was the only way to get the system turned on. As if, it would only start after caps/electronics charged up (for lack of better understanding how to describe it)
Initially, noticed two bulged caps near the cpu, one clearly vented.
I pounded google trying to diagnose/confirm my suspicion it was the mobo alone. Removing GPU, ram, and power to mobo. The whistle/noise remained until I took power from the mobo.. Did put my ear next to PSU and could hear no sound. Thought this confirmed my diagnosis... but now, after more reading, I'm no longer convinced.
Now that I have a replacement mobo enroute, I begin cleaning up the box.
</lead-in>
<PSU specific>
Pulled PSU to clean it. After cleaning, I plugged it in, and hear a whistle (maybe a hum) from it, GREAT! Research suggest it too could be bad caps or a transformer hum. Try using a straw to zone into the culprit but not sure of the result. It [the sound] appears to be coming from between the two heat sinks. There's two ceramic caps (blue in color), two Electrolytic Capacitors (black), a transformer and many smaller electronic components (resistors, etc) in the area. BTW, no caps appear to be swollen, bulged tops or electrolyte leakeage (top or bottom)
Next, I checked the voltage output of the PSU. 3.3V (3.7V measured) and 5V (5.4V measured). 12V +&- are slightly lower @ 11.78V. Checked voltage with power on jumped and a small case fan plugged in.
With no load on the PSU, power on not jumped, the sound is what might be described as a leaking cap (air escaping). It may be psychosomatic and only be a hum though *shruggs*. If I turn the switch off, the sound goes up in tone/frequency steadily and stops (1-3 seconds) abruptly.
With the power on circuit jumped and an old case fan plugged in, the sound is still there but it's different. In fact, it acts like a wave; meaning, the tone/frequency goes up and down (think wave form on an oscope). I guess I didn't hear this before cause of the cpu, hdd and case fans. Then again, maybe it's a recent thing and is the reason my system became unstable... eventually, unusable. Too, perhaps this is from almost zero load on the PSU, comparatively, to what is there when the system is together (mobo, ram, gpu, 3 hdd's, dvd drive, mouse, keyboard).
</PSU specific>
<Questions>
Did I give enough info to help diagnose the situation?
Does it appear that blaming the motherboard was premature or not, in whole, correct?
Is the sound now heard from the PSU, normal, for such a low-grade PSU? (just read the review on it from hardware secrets)
</Questions>
Final thoughts:
Thanks if you've read this far and/or have time to assist!
Any suggestions, recommendations, request for specific info, or chastisement; will be welcome.
~Steve
PS. Lucky for me, a fellow LUG member let me borrom an old emachine with a single core 64bit and 256mb ram. We did upgrade the ram for him by adding a 1GB stick from a local computer repair shop. Have much more appreciation for my old, pre-death-bed system now!

Comment