failing hard drives after sitting for years...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ChaosLegionnaire
    HC Overclocker
    • Jul 2012
    • 3261
    • Singapore

    #21
    Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

    Originally posted by eccerr0r
    I'm still not convinced enterprise grade drives are really more reliable than any other.
    yea and to add on to that. backblaze also did some tests and they also found that ssds werent any reliable than hdds either. so that sure debunked the long-ongoing myth that ssds are more reliable than their spinning rust counterparts. then to add on the fact that when ssds fail, all the data becomes garbled making data recovery near impossible. but then when hdds fail, they can also not spin up or the low-level disk data on the platters or the firmware chip becomes focked. this also makes data recovery very difficult.

    so in short, always backup your data indeed! as the advice around here goes. no method of data storage is ever bulletproof! never has been!

    Comment

    • dmill89
      Badcaps Legend
      • Dec 2011
      • 2531
      • USA

      #22
      Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

      Originally posted by ChaosLegionnaire
      yea and to add on to that. backblaze also did some tests and they also found that ssds werent any reliable than hdds either. so that sure debunked the long-ongoing myth that ssds are more reliable than their spinning rust counterparts.
      Yes and no. I don't dispute their findings, however it is important to consider the context of this testing, with the drives in a controlled data center environment and not regularly subject to shock/etc.

      While not exactly scientific my personal experience has been that when it comes to desktop drives it largely matches up with their data with little difference between failures od HDDs and SSDs, however with laptop drives (and other portable devices like older HDD based MP3/media players) that are often subject to movement and shock HDDs have a much higher failure rate. Back when we were still using laptops with mechanical HDDs at work very few laptops made it to their 3-4 year retirement date without at least one HDD replacement (it was/is common for people to carry their laptops to meetings with them still running, not a good practice, but given that they take several minutes to boot up with all the corporate bloatware, understandable), once we switched to laptops with SSDs failures became very rare.

      Granted with the high I/O loads of most "modern" OSs and HDDs poor random read/write speeds they are a pretty poor option for an OS drive with most current OSs regardless, largely limiting their usefulness to bulk data storage (a second drive in a PC specifically for data storage or a NAS).

      Comment

      • brethin
        Badcaps Legend
        • Dec 2008
        • 1907
        • USA

        #23
        Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

        Spinners don't die sitting if stored properly, unlike food in my refrigerator!

        Comment

        • Per Hansson
          Super Moderator
          • Jul 2005
          • 5895
          • Sweden

          #24
          Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

          Originally posted by ChaosLegionnaire
          yea and to add on to that. backblaze also did some tests and they also found that ssds werent any reliable than hdds either. so that sure debunked the long-ongoing myth that ssds are more reliable than their spinning rust counterparts.
          "The 2022 Drive States review is based on data recorded from 2,906 SSD boot units, Backblaze states, and it is essentially confirming what the company was saying in its 2022 mid-year report. SSDs are more reliable than HDDs, Backblaze says, as they show a lower AFR rate (0.98%) compared to HDDs (1.64%)."

          Source: https://www.techspot.com/news/97909-...backblaze.html
          "The one who says it cannot be done should never interrupt the one who is doing it."

          Comment

          • ChaosLegionnaire
            HC Overclocker
            • Jul 2012
            • 3261
            • Singapore

            #25
            Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

            nope. that translates into an afr difference of between 0.66%. 0.66% is statistically insignificant and will not translate into any noticeable difference in practice or in real world usage. backblaze mentioned that before in a previous report of theirs. funny how they omitted it. techspot is politically biased in favor of ssds for some reason.

            Comment

            • Per Hansson
              Super Moderator
              • Jul 2005
              • 5895
              • Sweden

              #26
              Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

              Originally posted by ChaosLegionnaire
              techspot is politically biased in favor of ssds for some reason.
              Ehh, no.
              If you pick up your calculator and divide 1.64 by two you will see that mechanical HDD's are twice as likely to fail as SSD's.
              But because you have some agenda to proove so fuck statistics and lets just make stuff up like we go, like Techspot is biased because they report on the actual statistics.
              Maybe you should become a politician.
              "The one who says it cannot be done should never interrupt the one who is doing it."

              Comment

              • eccerr0r
                Solder Sloth
                • Nov 2012
                • 8665
                • USA

                #27
                Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                come on, both of you are stretching the wording of the difference between failure rates...

                Comment

                • jiroy
                  Badcaps Legend
                  • Jun 2016
                  • 2416
                  • Lebanon

                  #28
                  Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                  Well , that really triggered my curiosity , so I dipped into my oldest hard disks , the ide ones . Some are 30 years old , probably . One of them , in the attached pictures is a 4.7 gb, lol ..
                  Anyway , I put them to the hardest test it can be ... Installing a system . Till now , the first 4 chosen had 4 different operational systems : w98SE , XPSP3 , VISTA Enterprise and W7 32 Bit .
                  All the tests were made successfully on a Acer Travelmate 7110 , probably my last system to have an ide slot .
                  Attached Files

                  Comment

                  • eccerr0r
                    Solder Sloth
                    • Nov 2012
                    • 8665
                    • USA

                    #29
                    Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                    I have not tested my 40MB IDE disk in ages.

                    The oldest HDD I've actually powered on in the last year or so may be one of the following:
                    a 2GB WD 3.5" IDE
                    a 700MB Quantum 3.5" SCSI
                    and I think I have a 400MB Conner (??) 3.5" IDE.
                    These disks were dumped in my old K6-233. At one point I did lvm on them so that I could get a bit more space out of them, but I just ignored them now since if one fails I lose the whole array...

                    ---

                    hmm... recently also picked up a 20GB (seagate), 210MB (conner), and 340MB (maxtor) 3.5" disks. Now I wonder if any of these actually work as I've been too lazy to test them. Probably should just pitch them if they don't.
                    Last edited by eccerr0r; 04-18-2023, 11:58 PM.

                    Comment

                    • jiroy
                      Badcaps Legend
                      • Jun 2016
                      • 2416
                      • Lebanon

                      #30
                      Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                      I'll keep my oldest old hard disks a secret ... Antics and collectors !!

                      Comment

                      • eccerr0r
                        Solder Sloth
                        • Nov 2012
                        • 8665
                        • USA

                        #31
                        Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                        I used to have ST412 and TM503 hard disks too...alas not sure if my parents tossed them.
                        One used to be able to store a whole OS in 10MB ...

                        BTW these disks *can* and have be low level formatted

                        (Also had in past: ST225R ST225N ST251 Miniscribe3425 and more ... alas unsure of their fates... but pretty sure these will work as these can always be LLFed again and again. Well not the ST225N, that one I'm not sure.)
                        Last edited by eccerr0r; 04-19-2023, 10:21 AM.

                        Comment

                        • eccerr0r
                          Solder Sloth
                          • Nov 2012
                          • 8665
                          • USA

                          #32
                          Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                          LOL I had a Conner CFS425 and a Conner CFS210 installed in a system. I accidentally set both to slave and was wondering why I suddenly had a CFS635 installed in my machine...

                          Comment

                          • jiroy
                            Badcaps Legend
                            • Jun 2016
                            • 2416
                            • Lebanon

                            #33
                            Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                            Those are for amateur collectors ... newbies

                            Comment

                            • ChaosLegionnaire
                              HC Overclocker
                              • Jul 2012
                              • 3261
                              • Singapore

                              #34
                              Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                              Originally posted by Per Hansson
                              Ehh, no.
                              If you pick up your calculator and divide 1.64 by two you will see that mechanical HDD's are twice as likely to fail as SSD's.
                              again misleading percentages and this isnt the first time someone has tried to post misleading percentages on this forum. the average home user and consumer typically runs less than a handful of drives. 1, 2 or 3% difference does jack on such a small sample size. if u run a data center with hundreds or thousands of drives then the difference may start to add up.
                              Originally posted by Per Hansson
                              But because you have some agenda to proove so fuck statistics and lets just make stuff up like we go, like Techspot is biased because they report on the actual statistics.
                              when u report on something u have to report the whole truth and nothing but the truth. this is a matter of principle, integrity and honesty. reporting half-truths or lying by omission is nothing more than propaganda and will be dismissed as such.
                              Originally posted by Per Hansson
                              Maybe you should become a politician.
                              thanks but i'd rather become a lawyer instead.
                              Originally posted by eccerr0r
                              LOL I had a Conner CFS425 and a Conner CFS210 installed in a system. I accidentally set both to slave and was wondering why I suddenly had a CFS635 installed in my machine...
                              huh? it actually added up the model numbers of the drives? im gonna assume this is a joke post, bro? unless its serious then do post a screenshot of the issue for our amusement.

                              Comment

                              • eccerr0r
                                Solder Sloth
                                • Nov 2012
                                • 8665
                                • USA

                                #35
                                Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                                No it wasn't a joke, it really did print it - but it was nonfunctional as a real disk. It's not actually adding, it's a bitwise or of the two.

                                Comment

                                • brethin
                                  Badcaps Legend
                                  • Dec 2008
                                  • 1907
                                  • USA

                                  #36
                                  Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                                  I have a small box of mfm and rll drives with the controllers and cabels, I should test them and see how they are.

                                  Comment

                                  • jiroy
                                    Badcaps Legend
                                    • Jun 2016
                                    • 2416
                                    • Lebanon

                                    #37
                                    Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                                    My final count on ide drives , 23 one working perfectly . Only 3 failed , but they were marked (bad sectors) by me sometime in the past . Amazingly , they're all speedy gonzales and fun to work with , despite working on 2 GB Rams only .
                                    I bet new drives ain't that reliable anymore ...
                                    Taking advantage now on some old programs and some of them are a real treaure .

                                    Comment

                                    • eccerr0r
                                      Solder Sloth
                                      • Nov 2012
                                      • 8665
                                      • USA

                                      #38
                                      Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                                      2 GB Rams??? What do you mean?

                                      I was testing the disks on my k6-233. Probably could use any PCI machine as I have a boatload of PCI IDE controllers...

                                      Comment

                                      • jiroy
                                        Badcaps Legend
                                        • Jun 2016
                                        • 2416
                                        • Lebanon

                                        #39
                                        Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                                        The Acer travelmate 7110 limit is 2 GB Rams , but I usually boost its performance with USB Sticks assigned into Rams .
                                        All older systems (laptops only) were and/or will be gifted to my friends at some point in time .. That's my habit .

                                        Comment

                                        • eccerr0r
                                          Solder Sloth
                                          • Nov 2012
                                          • 8665
                                          • USA

                                          #40
                                          Re: failing hard drives after sitting for years...

                                          Not an option on my K6-233, it's maxxed out at 256MB RAM and doesn't even cache it, won't cache unless it has less than 64MB RAM.

                                          At least it can deal with regular 3.5" (and even 5.25" FH) disks.

                                          Comment

                                          Related Topics

                                          Collapse

                                          • abajor
                                            Evaluating Mechanical Hard Drives SMART Data in Linux (Ubuntu) Using the Disks Utility.
                                            by abajor
                                            I've gotten into the habit of Looking at peoples Mechanical Hard drives with a Ubuntu thumb drive to boot their system.
                                            I understand the raw values are not really uniform between manufacturers, but I have noticed that high seek and read error raw values at the very least correlate to a drive that is going to have sub par access time, and extremely slow OS booting.
                                            The odd thing is I've often seen very high seek and read error rates on drives with fairly low on time.

                                            Does anybody have any other takes on evaluating smart data? I've used Crystal Disk Info, It seems to present...
                                            04-23-2024, 11:43 PM
                                          • simonsabato
                                            Help diagnosing black screen Panasonic TC-P60ZT60
                                            by simonsabato
                                            Hello to all, how have I not stumbled onto this excellent community in the past? I'm an engineer by trade, been hacking/repairing electronics since before I can remember ... sometimes to my parents annoyance Now I'm older and grayer and trying to kindle that "can do" mentality in my kids! so....

                                            Our Panny TC-P60ZT60 went black screen while my daughter was watching. I began with an appropriate amount of cursing HDMI and modern electronics is general, until my daughter reminded me that I design modern electronics. Moving on, I tried the unplug, factory reset, etc, eventually...
                                            11-03-2021, 01:13 AM
                                          • federalhouse
                                            **Need Help Unlocking BIOS and Hard Drive on Dell Precision 5820 Tower**
                                            by federalhouse
                                            Hi everyone,

                                            I'm in need of assistance with a Dell Precision 5820 Tower. The BIOS is locked with "Dell Security Manager," preventing access to the HDD-1 hard drive.


                                            **Background:**

                                            I recently purchased this Dell Precision 5820 Tower from a recycler who salvages equipment from abandoned office spaces. The computer was left behind by its previous owner and was password locked. Given that it can run Windows 11, I saw this as an opportunity to upgrade my setup.


                                            **What I've Tried So Far:**


                                            1. I accessed
                                            ...
                                            08-01-2024, 07:03 PM
                                          • ChaosLegionnaire
                                            what to do with faulty hard drives?
                                            by ChaosLegionnaire
                                            i have several dead/bricked (not detected, doesnt show up or making constant clicks of death) and faulty bad sector hard drives. im moving house soon and need to get rid of some dead weight.

                                            i thought of selling them for parts or not working but they are quite heavy and shipping each drive internationally via local post is US$23 each. im using some of the drives as gym strength training dumbells by putting 4 of them in a box to make a 3kg dumbell. but since im moving i cant carry the deadweight with me. any ideas what to do with them that is cost-effective for ppl like me...
                                            11-25-2021, 02:42 AM
                                          • NeedsPractice
                                            Best Overall Amazing Back Up Setup? 1K-4K Budget! Software + Hardware? Help!
                                            by NeedsPractice
                                            I remember a lot of people before when my hard drive failed told me that I could do a couple of amazing things with backing up data. What stuck out is two things...

                                            1. Software that will backup your data live via a cloud solution or over the internet without having a corporate cloud product.
                                            2. Get a storage tower with hard drives and load them up.

                                            What I mean is there software out there that you can install on your computer. You tell it which data you want backed up. Lets say your main PC with (2) hard drives and (8) hard drives connected to it via a tower....
                                            06-23-2023, 05:26 PM
                                          • Loading...
                                          • No more items.
                                          Working...