Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Moosiv
    Member
    • May 2021
    • 27
    • England

    #1

    Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

    Hey guys/gals - I'm very new to electronics repairs. I only have a few months experience to be honest but I'm managing to replace hdmi ports / hdmi retimer chips on consoles, mosfets and ic on laptops etc. However, I keep having a repeating scenario and I can't figure out, I'm missing something and I've been trying to figure it out for weeks but I've now got the same scenario again and I dont want to give up or pass the job on this time so if anyone could push me in the right direction I'd really appreciate it.

    This is the scenario, laptop board not switching on, I can confirm power into dc and first 2 mosfets. I can probe power rails around the board with mixed results but today the battery charging rail works (charges the battery orange to blue led) and 5v is there. I have a row of 6 coils not to far from the gpu (acer gaming laptop) and a row of 4 below cpu. all are shorted. I can't find any short at a mosfet. I'm injecting 1v at any coil and it will take any current I offer it - currently limited to 3a.

    My issue is this - I don't get any heat spots to detect the issue such as a bad cap - I'm pretty sure what I'm doing is the equivalent of pushing the voltage straight into ground. I'll upload a photo of the board I'm currently working on. Components marked red are shorted. Can't find schematic. Not that that usually helps me with this injecting voltage to find shorted component.

    If someone could prod me in the right direction I'd be very grateful.
    Attached Files
  • mon2
    Badcaps Legend
    • Dec 2019
    • 13834
    • Canada

    #2
    Re: Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

    A low resistance of the cpu or gpu rails does not indicate a short circuit. These rails are typically low voltage and respectively of low resistance so they are not a fault.

    Post the measured resistance in ohms to ground for the rails of concern.

    Comment

    • piernov
      Super Moderator
      • Jan 2016
      • 4435
      • France

      #3
      Re: Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

      https://www.badcaps.net/forum/showpo...02&postcount=2

      2.2. Don't suspect that something is shorted with no reason
      Shorted components are not the only failure mode of a laptop. Additionally, some places will measure low resistance to ground under normal operation. In general, high power low voltage (<2V) power rails will measure less than a few hundred ohms to ground. CPU VCore will measure a few ohms only. GPU VCore with newer NVidia GPU can even measure less than 1 ohm. It's normal. If you suspect a short to ground, always report your exact resistance to ground measurements.

      2.3. Never randomly inject voltage
      Voltage injection is used to find a short to ground. Only consider it after you found that there is a short to ground and after doing a visual inspection trying to find a broken component.
      OpenBoardView — https://github.com/OpenBoardView/OpenBoardView

      Comment

      • Moosiv
        Member
        • May 2021
        • 27
        • England

        #4
        Re: Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

        Right OK - so basically I'm barking up the wrong tree - that actually really helps - thanks guys! At least I can put that to bed and move on. I have some photos of the two rails in ohms.
        Attached Files

        Comment

        • mon2
          Badcaps Legend
          • Dec 2019
          • 13834
          • Canada

          #5
          Re: Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

          Where are you measuring the 0.5 ohms to ground ? Is it for the NVIDIA GPU rail ? That may be still ok.

          Also, I believe schematics are available from paid sites. The attached screen grab appears to match your PCB markings.
          Attached Files

          Comment

          • Moosiv
            Member
            • May 2021
            • 27
            • England

            #6
            Re: Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

            yes the nvidia rail

            Comment

            • reformatt
              Badcaps Legend
              • Feb 2020
              • 1398
              • Australia

              #7
              Re: Short detection - what am I doing wrong?

              If you manage to get the schematic for what you are working on, they usually have a power sequence diagram. Laptops power is one big combinational logic circuit, you need certain states to be good prior to moving to the next state.

              As a heads up, if there was an issue with a CPU or GPU being short, this is usually accompanied by a shorted FET on the buck converter feeding them. In that event, you'll see a dead short on the main power rail.

              Comment

              Related Topics

              Collapse

              • karlox
                Short board detection DAG7BJMB8C0 REV.C
                by karlox
                Good morning, I work on a HP motherboard, with a power problem, replace a pair of AOE6936 mosfets that had shorted, a failure of the integrated RT366AC, where the track 28 (VIN) is damaged (attached image) and where I have the doubt of the line that is just above it and making the measurement marks me short, and it is where I can not determine if the fault caused that it reached a GND layer of the card and on that line was the line (VIN) looking at the card more incidents of short on the line (VIN) I found the integrated (EM5209) attached data sheet and where the lines 1 and 2 that carry (VIN)...
                07-28-2023, 04:45 PM
              • DynaxSC
                Extreme High Current & Low Voltage Short Killer ??
                by DynaxSC
                Hi Folks

                I'm looking for a extreme high current short killer solution for a reasonable cost.

                I have an LGA1700 motherboard (ASUS PRIME Z790-P WiFi) where I exchanged the LGA socket already 3 times, and every time after the socket exchange I get a short of power supply lines VCORE (V variable) and VCCIN_AUX (1.8V).
                After taking off the socket, the shorts dissappear again.
                The soldermask on the socket is already partially demaged from the heat, so I have reconstructed the soldermask by manually painting the missing soldermask parts with a very small top of a...
                10-15-2024, 10:13 AM
              • Stephen
                MacBook Pro 14" A2442 Short on PPBUS_AON but no short present when injecting voltage!
                by Stephen
                I check PPBUS_AON and there is a short present on the line, the computer shows a short when testing for short to ground, so when I inject voltage into the line, I get 0AMPS so no short is showing up. I have replaced a blown cap on this board that exploded and tested for the short and it is now removed. Any suggestions? I tested voltage at the line when the fuses are connected and I am getting 1.2 Volts at the line.
                02-06-2025, 12:03 PM
              • Victor Moreira Silva
                Acer Nitro 5 LA-L181p power LED turns on by 5 secs (Short on PCH rail?)
                by Victor Moreira Silva
                Hello everyone,

                I'm trying to repair my old Acer Nitro 5 (AN517-54-55T5). I've already bought a new laptop, so this is more of a learning project. For the experience, with no high expectations of success.

                Well, my decice specs are the following:

                Model: Acer Nitro 5 AN517-54-55T5
                CPU: Intel Core i5-11400H
                GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1650
                Motherboard: GH51G LA-L181P Rev:1c

                The symptom:
                When pressing the power button, the power LED lights up for about 5 seconds and then turns off. Initially, the issue was intermittent: sometimes...
                05-26-2025, 10:49 AM
              • aaronkatrini
                Help me find the short circuit on this WORKING Nvidia GTX1650
                by aaronkatrini
                Hi all,

                Recently picked up this GTX1650 at a local flea market for a low price and wanted to use it on my secondary PC. I first tested the card and saw the fan spin for a split second and then nothing. Immediately I thought of a short circuit. Disassembled and found a shorted SMD capacitor, injected voltage into it (1V/4A) and two Mosfets got hot immediately (QN3103 & QN3107). Desoldered these Mosfets and the card turned back to life.

                Bought replacements from Aliexpress and replaced them afterwards. Tried the card but still the saw the fan spin for a split second...
                04-18-2024, 03:15 PM
              • Loading...
              • No more items.
              Working...