Try our *UPDATED* boardview, bios, & schematic search. Over 2.3 million files for download!

Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Nikochan
    Member
    • Sep 2013
    • 38
    • Turkey

    #1

    Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

    Hi. I have a desktop PC with an MSI 945G Platinum motherboard. I play my favorite old games on it. Sadly, one of the KZG series caps on the motherboard exploded yesterday and there are signs of leakage on top of a few others as well, so I'm thinking of replacing them.

    The KZG series caps on the motherboard are as follows:

    2 x 1000uF 6.3v M(105C) 5(7) 5C 10x12.5mm (one of these exploded yesterday)
    6 x 1800uF 16v M(105C) 4(2) ND 10x25mm


    (There are also 8 KZE series caps (1000uF 6.3v 8x15mm) on the mobo but they look okay).

    I couldn't find new KZGs anywhere so I'm thinking of ordering these Nichicons from the shop instead:

    Nichicon HN series 1000uF 6.3v 10x12.5mm
    Nichicon HZ series 1800uF 16v 10x25mm


    These Nichicons seem to have lower ESR values than the KZGs which is probably a good thing (I think). I'm hoping to replace the KZGs with better caps though. Would these Nichicons do the job?

    Need a bit of feedback on the issue before ordering the parts. I welcome any comments and suggestions. Thanks in advance.
  • Yatti420
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2008
    • 130
    • Canada
    • XBOX,Technology,Cars,Cats

    #2
    Re: Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

    The KZG are badcaps.. I've had bad KZE and KZJ aswell.. Thats why they have bulged/leaked.. Definitely get low ESR caps not general purpose.. Also watch out where you order from.. If on Ebay I'd go with egecku for caps.. Nobody else.. Recap the entire board.. If it literally blew up I'd check for other damage..

    https://www.badcaps.net/forum/showthread.php?t=425 FAQ

    Edit: Topcat has goodcaps here.. https://www.badcaps.net/pages.php?vid=26

    See ya,
    Last edited by Yatti420; 09-19-2013, 08:11 AM.

    Comment

    • mariushm
      Badcaps Legend
      • May 2011
      • 3799

      #3
      Re: Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

      KZG and KZJ are a known series of capacitors that has problems and eventually go bad.

      KZE is GOOD, it's not known as having issues and as far as I know, it has a different chemical composition compared to KZG and KZJ so it's unlikely to have the same flaws.

      KZG is discontinued.
      Nichicon HN and HZ are also discontinued, but they were discontinued recently (last year I think) so it's possible to still be stocked by stores. Be warned though, eBay may have fakes.

      Nichicon HM, HN, HZ should all be suitable. With that motherboard, Panasonic FM or FR should also work fine, even through they don't match exactly to the specs.

      Considering you're in Turkey, it may be expensive to get capacitors from Topcat, since he's in US. Good stores like www.farnell.net or http://www.rs-components.com/index.html may also have high shipping prices.

      As I'm in Romania, I'm willing to mail you some quality capacitors from my own stock, for basically the price I paid for them, plus 2$ for postage.
      I have

      Nichicon HM 1000uF 6.3v 8x15mm 0.5$ each

      Nichicon HM 1500uF 16v 10x20 mm 0.75$ each
      Panasonic FM 2200uF 16v 12.5x25 0.85$ each

      I don't have 1800uF but either 1500uF or 2200uF would work instead, as long as you can fit 12.5mm diameter capacitors I recommend the 2200uF ones.

      Comment

      • Nikochan
        Member
        • Sep 2013
        • 38
        • Turkey

        #4
        Re: Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

        Many thanks for your replies.

        @mariushm

        I don't think I have any another choice other than ordering online internationally and honestly, it's not the additional shipping costs that I'm worried about. Ordering from Topcat's shop costs only an additional $10, which isn't a big amount really and I bet ordering from Farnell or RS or even ebay would cost almost the same. Although I'm worried about whether or not I'll be able to receive the shipment, especially considering I may have to wait a few weeks for it to arrive, that's the biggest issue. So if I'm to wait that long, then I'd really want to get some good quality parts at least on par with the previous ones. None of the ones you have offered me is an exact match to KZGs or better. I've already checked the datasheets for Panasonics FC, FM and FR series but they all looked inferior to the KZGs (higher ESR, lower ripple).

        Rubycon has a few which have somewhat similar specs to KZGs BTW.

        Rubycon ZLG 6.3v 1000uF 10x12.5mm
        Rubycon ZLH 16v 1800uF 10x23mm


        Unfortunately, Topcat's shop doesn't seem to have these.

        I've also found a solid polymer on RS and I wonder if these can replace the KZG 1000uF.

        http://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/alumin...itors/7149553/


        PS. The top part of the exploded cap was slightly opened and there was some liquid oozing out of there. I haven't noticed any other damage aside from the small mark (probably due to the corrosive liquid?) on the cooler of my graphics card (on the plastic area which stands directly on top of that capacitor).
        Last edited by Nikochan; 09-19-2013, 10:17 AM.

        Comment

        • Nikochan
          Member
          • Sep 2013
          • 38
          • Turkey

          #5
          Re: Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

          Yesterday I received the Nichicon caps I had ordered from Topcat's shop. Took 10 days to arrive. Just FYI.

          Comment

          • theOracle
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2012
            • 165
            • USA

            #6
            Re: Need help finding replacements for KZG series caps

            Originally posted by mariushm
            KZG and KZJ are a known series of capacitors that has problems and eventually go bad.

            KZE is GOOD, it's not known as having issues and as far as I know, it has a different chemical composition compared to KZG and KZJ so it's unlikely to have the same flaws.
            Agreed, I install 10's of thousands of caps each year, similar to Topcat, and I have never seen or even heard of a failed KZE, can you double check that writing on the cap again?
            __________________


            the BIG 4

            ~~~ the top tier of low-ESR electrolytic capacitors ~~~

            Comment

            • Nikochan
              Member
              • Sep 2013
              • 38
              • Turkey

              #7
              Hi everyone. Apologies for posting in this very old thread after more than a decade but didn't want to create a new one for the same recapping issue. I've still been using the same motherboard which I already recapped it with Nichicons I bought from badcaps shop (which seems to be closed) but today I realized that I had somehow missed one KZG cap near the PCI-E slot. It's a NCC KZG 16V 470uF. 8x11 mm, I believe. Perhaps it seemed okay at the time but it now has a bit of bulging on the top and most likely gonna fail soon.

              I've looked quite a bit of places for a replacement for it, the only decent one I was able to find was a Panasonic FR series cap (EEUFR1C471) which has slightly worse ESR (0.036 vs 0.056) and ripple values (1140 vs 950). Would it work? Anyone has a similar experience with this type of replacement?

              KZG Series datasheet
              FR Series datasheet

              Image below is a different motherboard but it's the very same cap, the one near the PCI-E slot.

              Comment

              • stj
                Great Sage 齊天大聖
                • Dec 2009
                • 32065
                • Albion

                #8
                you can just use polymer caps now.
                kemet ones are cheap and easy to get.
                A750 range for example
                Attached Files

                Premium supporters get full download access and other benefits.

                Comment

              • stj
                Great Sage 齊天大聖
                • Dec 2009
                • 32065
                • Albion

                #9
                looks good, digikey has no stock though.

                Comment

                • Nikochan
                  Member
                  • Sep 2013
                  • 38
                  • Turkey

                  #10
                  Originally posted by stj
                  looks good, digikey has no stock though.
                  Not a problem, can't buy directly from them anyway due to import restrictions thanks to our government.

                  I hope it won't cause any incompatibility issues with the motherboard.

                  Come to think of it, I've been having a "restart" problem recently with this PC. It sometimes hangs on a blank screen just before POST when restarted from the OS or from BIOS, otherwise works normally when powered on or off. I wonder if this cap is the culprit.

                  Comment

                  • stj
                    Great Sage 齊天大聖
                    • Dec 2009
                    • 32065
                    • Albion

                    #11
                    no idea,
                    but i have recapped a 945 chipset board with almost 100% polymer caps and it runs great.
                    just dont use them for audio or video filtering circuits.

                    Comment

                    • Nikochan
                      Member
                      • Sep 2013
                      • 38
                      • Turkey

                      #12
                      Originally posted by stj
                      no idea,
                      but i have recapped a 945 chipset board with almost 100% polymer caps and it runs great.
                      just dont use them for audio or video filtering circuits.
                      Good to know, I might have to recap everything again at some point, it's been 13 years.

                      I've also found this Wurth brand cap which seems to have slightly better ESR/ripple values. What do you think? Slightly more expensive but I don't care.

                      https://docs.rs-online.com/1b55/0900766b8135ae95.pdf
                      https://www.digikey.com/en/products/...374007/5147483
                      https://eu.mouser.com/en/ProductDeta...F%252BGA%3D%3D

                      Comment

                      • stj
                        Great Sage 齊天大聖
                        • Dec 2009
                        • 32065
                        • Albion

                        #13
                        wurth are o.k. - i used some wurth polymers.
                        dont go too far with the esr on a circuit not designed for it.
                        i think i used PTG5 series. the other series have even lower esr

                        Comment

                        • momaka
                          master hoarder
                          • May 2008
                          • 12190
                          • Bulgaria
                          • Fixing stuff

                          #14
                          That 16V 470 uF KZG is for filtering the 12V rail going to the PCI-E slot and is directly connected to the PSU's 12V rail.
                          It's not that important of a cap, but it could become problematic for the board, if for example, you have a discreet GPU that tend to put out a lot of noise on the 12V rail of the PCI-E connector.
                          With that said, Panasonic FR, FM, or FS would all be fine here. You could probably go even lower (worse) like UCC KZE or even KY/KYB. Another alternative is Rubycon ZL or ZLH or ZLQ. From Nichicon, HW would be a decent enough match too... though probably HE will work OK too.
                          Or you can go the polymer route too. Anything there in the range of 150 to 470 uF will be fine.

                          As for the cold-boot issues - it's very unlikely for this to be caused from that KZG cap failing. If it's an Intel motherboard and you are using a stock Intel push-pin heatsink, that's probably done some damage to the CPU BGA by now. But before jumping to conclusions, it probably wouldn't hurt to re-seat all of the hardware on the motherboard a few times (RAM and add-on cards), including the CPU itself. Speaking of which, if you are using a discreet GPU, that could be on its way out too. I've seen this a lot with older Radeon HD series that loose an odd signal line on any of the PCI-E signal line pairs.
                          So in fewer words, I wouldn't put the intermittent cold-boot issue on anything just yet.

                          Comment

                          • Nikochan
                            Member
                            • Sep 2013
                            • 38
                            • Turkey

                            #15
                            Originally posted by momaka
                            That 16V 470 uF KZG is for filtering the 12V rail going to the PCI-E slot and is directly connected to the PSU's 12V rail.
                            It's not that important of a cap, but it could become problematic for the board, if for example, you have a discreet GPU that tend to put out a lot of noise on the 12V rail of the PCI-E connector.
                            With that said, Panasonic FR, FM, or FS would all be fine here. You could probably go even lower (worse) like UCC KZE or even KY/KYB. Another alternative is Rubycon ZL or ZLH or ZLQ. From Nichicon, HW would be a decent enough match too... though probably HE will work OK too.
                            Or you can go the polymer route too. Anything there in the range of 150 to 470 uF will be fine.
                            I've already ordered a pack of Panasonic FRs (8x11 mm) and was thinking of ordering a bunch of FMs which are a bit taller (8x15mm) but has closer specs to the KZG. I can possibly order stuff from Digikey via another company they work with, but they'd probably be quite a bit more expensive coming from the US. The ones I'm getting are from RS Online (UK), unfortunately they don't seem to have anything from UCC, Nichicon or Rubycon of this size and specs. I could only find Panasonic (as aluminum), Kemet and Wurth (as polymer). If I eventually get Panasonic FRs, FMs as well as Kemet/Wurth polymers, which one should I use?

                            Originally posted by momaka
                            As for the cold-boot issues - it's very unlikely for this to be caused from that KZG cap failing. If it's an Intel motherboard and you are using a stock Intel push-pin heatsink, that's probably done some damage to the CPU BGA by now. But before jumping to conclusions, it probably wouldn't hurt to re-seat all of the hardware on the motherboard a few times (RAM and add-on cards), including the CPU itself. Speaking of which, if you are using a discreet GPU, that could be on its way out too. I've seen this a lot with older Radeon HD series that loose an odd signal line on any of the PCI-E signal line pairs.
                            So in fewer words, I wouldn't put the intermittent cold-boot issue on anything just yet.
                            This isn't a cold-boot issue, in fact the cold-boot (powering on/off) is fine. I believe it's when the BIOS is used. The pre-POST hang only occurs on warm-boot (restart from within the OS, or from BIOS screen, i.e. when BIOS is skipped) and doesn't happen always, but it has become more frequent recently. When it happens I hear some fan(s) in the case start spinning really fast but I'm not sure which one. During this hang the reset button doesn't function (which seems more like a mobo issue), only holding the power button down (powering off) and then powering on fixes it. Monitor also loses the video signal when this happens, as if the PC is turned off completely, but it's not, since fans are still spinning. Perhaps the CPU hangs for some reason, I don't really know. When I'm replacing the cap, I'll take a look at the caps I had replaced before, the ones around the CPU/VRMs, perhaps one of them might have gotten bad.

                            Indeed, it's an Intel 945G motherboard with Pentium D 820 CPU. Not a push-pin heatsink, I've been using it with TT Big Typhoon for the past 20 years. I'm using it with a Sapphire Radeon HD 4850, which replaced an Asus ATI AX800 or something, forgot the model. interesting that you've mentioned as a common issue, is this issue something repairable? (PSU is a fairly old modular Seasonic).

                            Comment

                            • stj
                              Great Sage 齊天大聖
                              • Dec 2009
                              • 32065
                              • Albion

                              #16
                              Panasonic FR/FS are the only low esr caps you can still get at a reasonable price, sometimes some rubycon ZLx stuff.
                              low esr stuff is all using polymer now.

                              btw, on intel boards of that age if the bios gets corrupt the board will shutdown and restart 3 times - so if you see the fans doing that you know why.

                              Comment

                              • Nikochan
                                Member
                                • Sep 2013
                                • 38
                                • Turkey

                                #17
                                Originally posted by stj
                                btw, on intel boards of that age if the bios gets corrupt the board will shutdown and restart 3 times - so if you see the fans doing that you know why.
                                Thanks for the info though that sounds like a different issue than what I have. BTW, mine is an MSI motherboard with Intel 945G chipset (MS-7176).

                                Comment

                                • momaka
                                  master hoarder
                                  • May 2008
                                  • 12190
                                  • Bulgaria
                                  • Fixing stuff

                                  #18
                                  Originally posted by Nikochan
                                  If I eventually get Panasonic FRs, FMs as well as Kemet/Wurth polymers, which one should I use?
                                  It won't really matter which one you use.
                                  As I mentioned, that cap is not doing anything important, so you're free to use whatever you like or have on hand.
                                  I've even used a regular 85C cap in such a spot before with a 4.7 uF MLCC (ceramic SMD cap) soldered across the leads on the bottom of the board. This way, the MLCC would handle all of the high-frequency filtering and the 85C GP cap the lower frequency stuff.

                                  BTW, in regards to other places to get caps from, I've ordered from a few sellers in China before. Their names escape me now, but they did send me genuine electrolytic caps. The one guy that I got my 10V 2200 uF UCC KY from were NOS from 10+ years. But so far, I haven't had any problems with any of them coming back for the few years I have been using them.
                                  So with that said, genuine Japanese caps do exist on Ebay and for a reasonable price too. You just have to look for the larger lots of 20+ pieces. Some have very good prices at 100 pieces.

                                  Originally posted by Nikochan
                                  This isn't a cold-boot issue, in fact the cold-boot (powering on/off) is fine. I believe it's when the BIOS is used. The pre-POST hang only occurs on warm-boot (restart from within the OS, or from BIOS screen, i.e. when BIOS is skipped) and doesn't happen always, but it has become more frequent recently.
                                  Ah OK, that definitely does *not* sound like a cap issue, since the ESR of caps improves with higher temperatures - especially that of marginal or starting-to-fail caps.

                                  Originally posted by Nikochan
                                  Perhaps the CPU hangs for some reason, I don't really know. When I'm replacing the cap, I'll take a look at the caps I had replaced before, the ones around the CPU/VRMs, perhaps one of them might have gotten bad.
                                  If you used good quality Japanese caps, it's very unlikely any of them to have gone bad. And again, the ESR on electrolytic caps goes lower as their temperature increases. So if anything, stability should be even better from a non-cold boot - at least when it comes to voltage rails filtered by electrolytic caps.

                                  Originally posted by Nikochan
                                  I'm using it with a Sapphire Radeon HD 4850, which replaced an Asus ATI AX800 or something, forgot the model. interesting that you've mentioned as a common issue, is this issue something repairable?
                                  If it's a failing GPU - no. Just going to get worse and worse until it stops working completely someday.
                                  That said, the HD4k series are pretty robust GPUs. But like many cards of that time, their coolers were undersized for their TDP (thermal power output). The reference cooler cards were the worst, because for those, ATI/AMD had set the cooling profile to let the card run way too hot - typically waiting until it cooked past 75-80C before the fan would start to spin faster. And that's why so many HD4850 and 4870 cards failed so often and/or so early. If you edit the cooling profile so that the card starts ramping up the fan earlier and ideally stays below 60-65C at all times, that should really help keep the GPU survive longer.

                                  Comment

                                  • Nikochan
                                    Member
                                    • Sep 2013
                                    • 38
                                    • Turkey

                                    #19
                                    Originally posted by momaka
                                    It won't really matter which one you use.
                                    As I mentioned, that cap is not doing anything important, so you're free to use whatever you like or have on hand.
                                    I've even used a regular 85C cap in such a spot before with a 4.7 uF MLCC (ceramic SMD cap) soldered across the leads on the bottom of the board. This way, the MLCC would handle all of the high-frequency filtering and the 85C GP cap the lower frequency stuff.
                                    Okay, then I'll probably use a Panasonic FR/FM for now with relatively close specs to the KZG, I'll still buy some polymers (Kemet or Wurth) as a backup.

                                    Originally posted by momaka
                                    BTW, in regards to other places to get caps from, I've ordered from a few sellers in China before. Their names escape me now, but they did send me genuine electrolytic caps. The one guy that I got my 10V 2200 uF UCC KY from were NOS from 10+ years. But so far, I haven't had any problems with any of them coming back for the few years I have been using them.
                                    So with that said, genuine Japanese caps do exist on Ebay and for a reasonable price too. You just have to look for the larger lots of 20+ pieces. Some have very good prices at 100 pieces.
                                    Unfortunately, the government made it impossible to buy anything from places like Ebay or AliExpress etc. as an individual. You can still order it but you'd have to deal with customs bureaucracy as if you're importing a massive lot commercially and potentially pay a lot of money as customs tax. There are some companies which do all that for you, if you order it from places like Digikey, RS Components etc. which is what I'm ordering with.

                                    Originally posted by momaka
                                    Ah OK, that definitely does *not* sound like a cap issue, since the ESR of caps improves with higher temperatures - especially that of marginal or starting-to-fail caps.
                                    Honestly, I have no idea. When I'm replacing the cap, I'll probably do a more extensive inspection. It sounds like a motherboard problem to me but I may be wrong.

                                    BTW this is the motherboard MSI 945G Platinum. The 'G' supported onboard VGA if I recall correctly, which was the difference between the 945G and 945P Platinum.

                                    Click image for larger version  Name:	five_pictures9_194_24be75817751827684dbd3cd46c7c275.webp Views:	5 Size:	58.7 KB ID:	3957690


                                    https://us.msi.com/Motherboard/945G_.../Specification

                                    (I've noticed that it says "945P Platinum" on the image despite coming from the 945G's page, but they are pretty much identical)

                                    Originally posted by momaka
                                    If you used good quality Japanese caps, it's very unlikely any of them to have gone bad. And again, the ESR on electrolytic caps goes lower as their temperature increases. So if anything, stability should be even better from a non-cold boot - at least when it comes to voltage rails filtered by electrolytic caps.
                                    Can't remember what caps I used, pretty sure they were some Nichicon or Rubycons with similar or better specs than the KZGs. They should be okay then.

                                    Originally posted by momaka
                                    If it's a failing GPU - no. Just going to get worse and worse until it stops working completely someday.
                                    That said, the HD4k series are pretty robust GPUs. But like many cards of that time, their coolers were undersized for their TDP (thermal power output). The reference cooler cards were the worst, because for those, ATI/AMD had set the cooling profile to let the card run way too hot - typically waiting until it cooked past 75-80C before the fan would start to spin faster. And that's why so many HD4850 and 4870 cards failed so often and/or so early. If you edit the cooling profile so that the card starts ramping up the fan earlier and ideally stays below 60-65C at all times, that should really help keep the GPU survive longer.
                                    I don't think I have ever seen this GPU go past 60C when under load, the hottest temps are usually something between 54-55C when I'm playing games, usually 32-36 when idle (when room temp is around 22-24C). In fact, sometimes the motherboard temp (not CPU) is slightly higher than GPU (when idle), as the cooler's fan (Thermaltake Big Typhoon) blows downwards toward the motherboard, which I never liked but it was the best cooler around at the time.

                                    I no longer have the box but this should be it (Sapphire HD 4850 1GB VRAM):

                                    https://www.newegg.com/sapphire-tech...82E16814102837

                                    Click image for larger version  Name:	14-102-837-02.jpg Views:	0 Size:	217.3 KB ID:	3957684









                                    Comment

                                    • ChaosLegionnaire
                                      HC Overclocker
                                      • Jul 2012
                                      • 3297
                                      • Singapore

                                      #20
                                      luckily, the bios chip on that board is socketed, so u can pry it off and swap the bios chip if its truely wonky. i've heard of intel boards of that era that wont come back from a restart or reboot. replacing the bios chip fixed that issue. seems there was a "bios flash chip plague" from those years causing problems later on.

                                      as for the pci-e cap, yes its not really important because the video card itself also has 16v caps that filter the 12v power coming from the pci-e slot. add to that, the video card u are using draws more of its power from the 6 pin pci-e power connector rather than the mobo slot. if u are adventurous, u can even try running it without the cap if u need to use your computer urgently... hehehe... say for ordering stuff from china for the upcoming singles day sale mega discount of the year.

                                      so just order whatever capacitance values are more cost effective for you. only the voltage and the dimension should be the same to ensure it fits and isnt too tall as it might block the video card from being inserted if its too tall since its located below or to the left of pci-e x16 slot. if its too tall, it might collide with the heatsink, preventing the video card from going in.

                                      Comment

                                      Related Topics

                                      Collapse

                                      Working...