Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Miller Diversion 165 TIG no arc

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #21
    pic and atmel are interesting, if they are locked they return semi-random data to throw people off.
    most other controllers just return FF

    Comment


      #22
      Originally posted by stj View Post
      pic and atmel are interesting, if they are locked they return semi-random data to throw people off.
      most other controllers just return FF
      Well... so much to trying to get a dump file from it. That was totally wasted time. Dang! First time I read that Atmega, I figured there is something wrong with the dump. I've seen corrupted flashes on Atmegas before, but none of them did that. Anyway... only because that the Atmega is doing its security protect chit, doesn't mean something all is o,k. with its internal programming. Seen tons of these chips that go corrupt after years of working fine. To get them back in working order was to re-flash them and all is o.k. once more. Not so sure where to go from here now, but the problem is for sure here on the brains side of the board. Would be nice having a working unit to see how they compare.

      Comment


        #23
        I understand why you would lock down a controller chip but the manufacturer should offer the controller chip for replacement this is nonsense that they are not required to do this so you end up with a piece of equipment that is DOA and nothing else you can really do unless you get lucky and find another one with different issues and repair one of them and have spare parts

        Or sometimes you get lucky and they offer a replacement controller board but usually more expensive that way and sometimes it does not make sense to replace it because the cost about half of what equipment cost new really

        I have had this happen to many times over the years of doing repairs on my own equipment that somehow you get use to it as the way it is and deal with it
        Last edited by sam_sam_sam; 05-25-2025, 09:40 AM.

        Comment


          #24
          Originally posted by sam_sam_sam View Post
          I understand why you would lock down a controller chip but the manufacturer should offer the controller chip for replacement this is nonsense that they are not required to do this so you end up with a piece of equipment that is DOA and nothing else you can really do unless you get lucky and find another one with different issues and repair one of them and have spare parts

          Or sometimes you get lucky and they offer a replacement controller board but usually more expensive that way and sometimes it does not make sense to replace it because the cost about half of what equipment cost new really

          I have had this happen to many times over the years of doing repairs on my own equipment that somehow you get use to it as the way it is and deal with it
          They DO offer a replacement board… for a low price of $2000.00!!! The owner bought the whole machine for $1600 back in 2010 brand new. A replacement machine whatever they have now is $6800.00!!!

          Comment


            #25
            Found this tool called XPROG which claims to be able to read the code from ATMEGA MCU
            https://www.eldb.eu/index.php?route=...ormation_id=18
            It's expensive though, about 1300eur for the "base" version, what it does is somehow "glitch" the voltage to the MCU and that way bypass the code protect bits

            That tool is mostly used for car ECU programming

            I haven't found a DIY way, but it involves voltage glitching the MCU with precise timing

            Comment


              #26
              Originally posted by m1ch43lzm View Post
              Found this tool called XPROG which claims to be able to read the code from ATMEGA MCU
              https://www.eldb.eu/index.php?route=...ormation_id=18
              It's expensive though, about 1300eur for the "base" version, what it does is somehow "glitch" the voltage to the MCU and that way bypass the code protect bits

              That tool is mostly used for car ECU programming

              I haven't found a DIY way, but it involves voltage glitching the MCU with precise timing
              Yep, I know about voltage glitching to extract firmware. There are others too besides Xprog. I guess I am screwed with this firmware extraction idea unless I take the chip off and send it somewhere to get it done.

              Comment


                #27
                ^ And that's with the continued presumption that the issue with this welder is in the firmware IC and not something else.
                I do wonder what would happen if you ask Miller to re-program that firmware for you. Well, I know, probably they will just tell you to f-off and buy a new board. But sometimes you can't be 100% sure unless you ask.

                Comment


                  #28
                  Originally posted by momaka View Post
                  ^ And that's with the continued presumption that the issue with this welder is in the firmware IC and not something else.
                  I do wonder what would happen if you ask Miller to re-program that firmware for you. Well, I know, probably they will just tell you to f-off and buy a new board. But sometimes you can't be 100% sure unless you ask.
                  Tried that and they are only interested on me leaving $2k on the table and replace the board. Even sez so in their service manual which I got my grimy little fingers on.

                  Comment


                    #29
                    I went back at it again for a little bit to rule out the optocouplers and all the little MLCC caps. Even chased around resistance readings, no go.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X