Removing electrical noise introduced by fan

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • tony359
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Oct 2018
    • 256
    • United Kingdom

    #1

    Removing electrical noise introduced by fan

    Hi all,

    I am working on a sound processor, it tends to overheat so I fitted a fan inside. The fan is connected to the +15V of the PSU via a DC-DC converter based on the LM2596 to reduce the voltage to around 10.5V.

    Unfortunately the analogue circuitry is picking up the noise from the fan in two ways:
    1. The fan is close to the analogue section, the motor itself gets into the outputs so I'll have to move it somewhere else
    2. Even with the fan running outside of the case, there is still some noise which is clearly going back to the processor via power line. It disappears if I power the fan with an external PSU.

    I'll take care of point 1, but what about point 2? Any suggestions on how I can shield the noise coming from the fan?

    Attached a spectrum analysis of the output, you can see the 271Hz noise peak - and the scope is showing some noise with a 271Hz period on the DC line going to the fan.

    Is there a simple solution to this? Thanks!

    Edit: I tried replacing the LM2596 with a resistor but I still see noise going back. I've also tried with a linear regulator and it's the same. I need to find a way to stop the noise FROM the fan to go back via power line.
    Last edited by tony359; 11-28-2023, 05:52 AM.
  • tony359
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Oct 2018
    • 256
    • United Kingdom

    #2
    I've been experimenting with low pass filters. The best outcome - complete removal of noise - was with using the coil of a primary transformer and a 1000uF capacitor. I don't have inductors handy so that was a test. However I've also achieved a very good result with a 4.8Ohm resistor and a 1000uF capacitor, the noise is now much manageable. I'm not skilled enough to be able to calculate what inductor I might need for a low pass filter so feel free to chime in! Oh, the filter shall be small and not very expensive

    Outcome is attached.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	WhatsApp Image 2023-11-28 at 15.17.45_fe493f52.jpg
Views:	175
Size:	153.1 KB
ID:	3154840

    Fun fact: another fan I have delivers a much higher noise on the line and over many harmonics. Attached.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	WhatsApp Image 2023-11-28 at 14.59.36_733ecddb.jpg
Views:	135
Size:	165.0 KB
ID:	3154841

    Comment

    • redwire
      Badcaps Legend
      • Dec 2010
      • 3900
      • Canada

      #3
      How big is the fan? It's 12V? 1,000uF is huge. An inductor is only useful at high frequencies, not the BLDC motor pitch 171Hz.
      I find the chinese LM2596 switcher boards are junk - counterfeit IC's and very noisy, need a lot of capacitance added to the input and output and even then they are low efficiency.
      Maybe look for other power supply rails you can take power from, like the VFD filaments that are not sensitive to noise.
      Or the relay power rail.

      Comment

      • tony359
        Badcaps Veteran
        • Oct 2018
        • 256
        • United Kingdom

        #4
        I have +5, -15 and +15. I could try 5V fans and the 5V rail. However it's not the LM2596, the same happens with a resistor in its place.

        I've resolved with a resistor and a capacitor. 10Ohm resistor, 1000uF capacitor. The noise has disappeared completely.

        But you might be right in suggesting a different rail. Maybe the 5V one is less critical as relays are powered by it. Though, they're muting relays, when they're activated, it means sound is muted
        The original design of the PCB allowed for a fan which was never implemented and it was off the 15V rail though.

        Fan is 60mm 12V.

        Comment

        • прямо
          Badcaps Veteran
          • Sep 2022
          • 261
          • Indonesia

          #5
          If a small 5V DC fan less than 1W is good enough to help dissipate the heat, you could use a 5V ground isolator BS0505S-1W, because it removes Bluetooth and USB VBUS noise completely.

          Comment

          Related Topics

          Collapse

          • Asxetos21
            Dell Latitude 5511 audible electrical noise
            by Asxetos21
            I have a Dell Latitude 5511 laptop, and lately, a faint but clearly audible electrical (crackling) noise comes from the motherboard, similar to the random clicking coming from a mechanical hdd's heads moving inside it.
            The laptop shows no signs of malfunction, and clearly this is electrical not mechanical, so my suspicion goes to a dodgy component in the power rails (a capacitor or a coil?). I fear this could develop into a serious damage.

            Any advise on how to narrow it down?
            The schematic is available here:
            Dell Latitude 5510 5511 - Precision 3551 FDV50 FDV51 LA-J282P...
            03-03-2025, 09:53 AM
          • MegaZAC
            Onkyo TX-SR805 noise in one channel
            by MegaZAC
            Surprisingly enough, this receiver doesn't have the DSP chip issue. The HDMI board does not get hot, and sound over HDMI works fine.

            Regardless of the input, the right channel has noise that is clearly noticeable even on average volume level. The only cases when there's no noise is when VCR input is selected (some tracks on the board are damaged, maybe that's why), or if HDMI input is selected but nothing plugged into it. In all other cases, even when no input is connected I still have the noise.

            There's some logic behind it. As soon as I select an input I get only left...
            04-23-2025, 10:09 PM
          • howardc64
            A1312 (27” iMac 2009-2011) A1407 (Thunderbolt Display) A1316 (Cinema Display) Display Black Screen Repair
            by howardc64
            Problem

            This is an LG edge LED lit LCD Display. The LEDs are on the bottom edge of the display. There are 2 bars (left and right) Each bar has many LEDs and a 6 pin connector. Each pin drive several LEDs thus is the highest current flow / heat junction. The weak lead free solder gradually fails with thermal expansion/contraction cycling and increases resistance. PSU will compensate up to a point, then when the current is too high, PSU just shut down the backlight causing a dark display. I have even seen one which the connector just fell off as solder points became completely detached....
            08-04-2024, 10:36 PM
          • courtcircuit
            Philips HTS8000 home cinema noise problem
            by courtcircuit
            Hello

            I have since a long time a Philips HTS8010S/01 which has been old but was doing the job.

            Since a few days, it starts by making a weird "static" nois when switches on for a few seconds to a minute and then works like a charm.
            Noise loudly outputs from the 3 channels, even if no signal is sent by the controler.DVD to the subwoofer/amp unit.

            I was thinking of a soldering that was starting to be damaged and that was only doing the job after a few seconds of heating, most probbaly on the power board
            Removed each of tyhe boards
            ...
            02-08-2025, 08:22 AM
          • sew333
            Apartment to buy with coal heating. Any sense to buy electrical heater and new pc?
            by sew333
            Hi guys. I have an question. Overall i am currently selling my house ( apartment with 1 room ) to buy some cheaper with 1 room too, and save cash for new pc in autumn 2024.

            So i choosed some cheaper apartment in smaller city,but there is coal heating. I dont wanna heat for coal.
            So i m thinking to buy electrical heater. And my question . Is this any sense to buy electrical heater when i will be using new pc with rtx 5090 and new intel ( when will be released ) ultra + Psu Seasonic 1600W?
            I expect that i will pay more for bills. But i wanna know this. Will using electrical...
            06-14-2024, 07:30 AM
          • Loading...
          • No more items.
          Working...