Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Check your notebook heatsink

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Check your notebook heatsink

    I own an Acer Aspire 5672WLMi, a replacement for a previous, unrecoverable Acer notebook that service assistance sent me in April 2006.
    It's one of first dual core notebooks (Core Duo T2300, not Core 2 Duo) with an Ati X1400 discrete graphics, 2 GB of ram, hdd 120 GB and other optionals: a really expensive computer at the time.

    My notebook's temp has gradually risen in last months, despite my decision to undervolt the cpu and to keep the graphic chip always on battery mode (reduced clock and voltage, so it heat a lot less): last week it turned idling at about 52 C / 126 F and it reached 77 C / 171 F under stress testing, running both Prime95 and Glxgears (openGl software emulation using MesaGL libraries under Cygwin) at the same time.
    Now is spring, here air temp is about 15 C / 60 F at noon but in summer it peaks up to 40 C / 104 F with specific humidity well over 80%: a living hell.
    Fearing for its life, yesterday I put it into maintentance: removed all screws and components, I was astonished by its heatsink.



    Dust didn't clogged the heatsink, but stopped on radiator fins (1): this is even worse because I was unable to blow air into fins with an air can and dust acted as a filter, killing both ventilation and heat transfer.
    Moreover, I realized that Acer didn't put any thermal compond on cpu becuase the heatsink was clean (2) and the few paste on the Ati chip was dry : no doubt temps were high, there was no way to effectively cool them. After cleaning the heatsink, I put some silver compound on both chips and reassembled the notebook: now is better than new, idling at about 45-50 C (113-122 F) and peaking at about 57 C (135 F). Idle temps are as high as before because the thermocontrolled fan will spin only above 50 C, but load one is a lot lower: success gained

    Screw you Acer and your stinginess: is sparing few cents, the cost of thermal compound on large scale, good enough or is better to avoid a lot of failure due to overheating? I'm not joking, this model (and others from Acer Folio generation) is nicknamed stove because it heats so much I began to be worried since beginning. Till yeasterday I couldn't understand why: the cpu is a lot cooler than previous Athlon 64 and Pentium 4 with their noisy fans spinning everytime, the graphic chip is a low class one and it's almost always in idle ...
    Now the answer is stinginess: a cent spared is a cent saved, hundred of thousand cents are thousand dollars. True, but I won't save anything if the computer burns after warranty expires

    Sorry for my rant.

    Zandrax
    Last edited by zandrax; 04-24-2008, 04:45 PM.
    Have an happy life.

    #2
    Re: Check your notebook heatsink

    can't see that pic.

    Comment


      #3
      Re: Check your notebook heatsink

      Sorry: I don't know why it seems uploaded to me.

      I'll reupload here:



      Zandrax
      Attached Files
      Have an happy life.

      Comment


        #4
        Re: Check your notebook heatsink

        my sister has simillar model but with turion.
        amount of noise and heat coming from it is really ridiculous when i compare it to my lenovo c2d laptop.
        also the amount of rf interference.
        to that extent i always laugh at fcc statement we see on machines:
        "(1) These devices may not cause harmful interference, and (2) these devices must accept any interference received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. "

        yeah, the 2) is rather important. what it can accept and it seems what it produces is not that important....huh...

        Comment


          #5
          Re: Check your notebook heatsink

          Originally posted by i4004
          my sister has simillar model but with turion.
          amount of noise and heat coming from it is really ridiculous when i compare it to my lenovo c2d laptop.
          also the amount of rf interference.
          to that extent i always laugh at fcc statement we see on machines:
          "(1) These devices may not cause harmful interference, and (2) these devices must accept any interference received, including interference that may cause undesired operation. "

          yeah, the 2) is rather important. what it can accept and it seems what it produces is not that important....huh...
          I've never understood part 2. Why are devices *required* to accept interference? What the hell, is there a conspiracy brewing to take over all the world's machines at some point?

          Comment


            #6
            Re: Check your notebook heatsink

            lol!

            Comment


              #7
              Re: Check your notebook heatsink

              Most TIM i have seen on laptops are from the very solid type. Thus after a few months it brakes and up then it does not assure good contact any more.
              Apart from the fact, that those TIM`s aren`t even good right from the start, i don`t like anything which hardens.
              So i usually replace the bad stuff always with Arctic Ceramique, which has prove long therm reliability and very good TIM properties.
              Silver stuff is too messy if you ask me, but sure i have it here too ;-) If Coollaboratory Liquid Metal would be longterm reliable. i would certainly use it.
              But to much scar stories about it, that it will form a kind of alloy and hardens.

              Comment


                #8
                Re: Check your notebook heatsink

                Originally posted by i4004
                my sister has simillar model but with turion.
                amount of noise and heat coming from it is really ridiculous when i compare it to my lenovo c2d laptop.
                It's perhaps the infamous Aspire 5024?
                Is it is, then I'm sorry for your sister: it's a stove even worse than mine.
                It heats a lot, USB transfert is slow and even the hard drive overheats, leading to corrupted sectors; other had problems with the dvd drive or the lcd screen, but these aren't widespread.
                Gift her a cooling notebook base and, if out of warranty, check its heatsink as I did.

                Zandrax
                Have an happy life.

                Comment

                Working...