Gigabyte 8IRX,Chemicon KY ,KZE Okay for Recap?

[supersabre]

I have decided to recap the P4 Gigabyte 8IRX, but i am just wonder whether it is okay to recap it using Chemicon KY or KZE capacitors.

According to one of the disscussions in this forum, KY and KZE are ideal for PIII only.
Is it okay to recap P4 motherboard using KY or KZE caps?

Also, which cap is better in term of life time and ESR, Chemicon KY or KZE?

https://www.badcaps.net/forum/showthread.php?t=1191

Nichicon NCC Rubycon SANYO Remarks
VZ KMG YXA MV-CZ 105C General Purpose
PW LXZ - MV-CX Miniature, Low ESR
HE KY YXG MV-CA K6, K6-2, P2, P3 grade
HD KZE ZL MV-WX K7, P3 grade
HV KZH ZLH - Extra long life, miniature, Low ESR
HM KZG MBZ MV-WG K7, K8, P4, P4+ high quality grade
HN KZJ MCZ - Ultra Low ESR
HZ - - - Lowest ESR of all electrolyte capacitors

[gonzo0815]

Re: Gigabyte 8IRX,Chemicon KY ,KZE Okay for Recap?

Most P4 motherboards are desinged for lowest ESR caps, thus i would not suggest to use KZE or KY lines. For p4 i would rather use Rubycon MCZ or the equivalent ultra low esr series from other mfk. In any way, it depend on the desing of the board. The older boards, like your p3 ones, are desinged for not that low esr caps, as they wheren`t availiable at that time. Thus it is not necessary to use the lowest ESR caps with their usually very low endurance (most are 2000h@105°c).