Thank you to the guys at HEGE supporting Badcaps [ HEGE ] [ HEGE DEX Chart ]

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Bad manufacturing?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Bad manufacturing?

    Whatever you do, don't buy an XFX Radeon graphics card (at least not the R7950 DD 3GB flavour) - mine died in spectacular fashion last night after 2 months of service...

    I have hardly been stressing the damn thing (work away a lot and the PC is at my mum's so doesn't get used when I'm at home) and while playing a quick game of Bioshock Infinite last night the following chain of events occurred:

    1. I heard a clicking sound from inside the PC.
    2. Clicking progressed to a grinding within seconds
    3. PC went off (panic time!) - this happened before I could do my usual "reach around the back and hit the power switch" method of saving myself from expensive hardware failures
    4. I opened up the case to investigate
    5. The offending graphics card was so hot I couldn't actually touch it and was ticking (sound of something contracting as it cooled)
    6. waited until the card was cool enough to pull out and found that one of the fans had shattered
    7. temp installed an old PCI-E R370 card I had laying around to make sure nothing else was fried
    8. PC booted up fine

    Upshot is I'm now running with my old Geforce GTX460 until I hear back from Scan on an RMA - hoping they can swap the POS card for a better (non-XFX) one now...

    A cursory googling leads me to believe this is not an isolated incident with this particular card - looking at other people's experiences it would appear that the cooler has a nasty tendency to warp (which in my case I can only surmise caused the fan to hit the shroud and disintegrate).

    PC won't POST with the card in there so I would assume that something is shorted out (caps all look good but I haven't bothered investigating any further as it's under warranty).

    All PSU voltages are within spec so I know it has to be the card itself (and it's rock-solid stable again now with the geforce in there).

    #2
    Re: Bad manufacturing?

    Had a similar issue with two xfx 6870, the fan was rubbing against the shroud. Had to take it apart and sand down the shroud to free up some space.

    Comment


      #3
      Re: Bad manufacturing?

      I try to stay away from XFX... I've had my HIS 7950 3GB for 9 months now almost running 24/7 the entire time and playing lots of games, haven't had any issues. At least you can still return yours.

      Comment


        #4
        Re: Bad manufacturing?

        I have an ASUS RHD 6570, and it seems to be working fine although the fan has gotten very noisy.

        Comment


          #5
          Re: Bad manufacturing?

          I had two XFX GTX 285 black editions (superclocked) running in SLI for years, till I burnt one up with a bad PSU, now I only have one, still working great
          Cap Datasheet Depot: http://www.paullinebarger.net/DS/
          ^If you have datasheets not listed PM me

          Comment

          Working...
          X