Alternating current & neutral wire

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • keyboardcowboy
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2006
    • 73

    #1

    Alternating current & neutral wire

    Our electrical suppply in our home is alternating current (a.c)
    right?
    Since a.c current keeps on changing direction why is it that in our home only the live wire carry electricity while the neutral wire is neutral.Shouldn't the neutral wire also be charged half the time.The live wire can be both positive and
    negative and so can the neutral wire
  • pentium
    Badcaps Legend
    • Mar 2006
    • 2778
    • Canada

    #2
    Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

    Yes homes use AC. DC would use large cables to prevent high current loss.
    You can reverse the hot with the neutral, it's just not safe to do.
    Find Nedry!


    Check the Vending machines!!

    <----Computer says I need more beer.

    Comment

    • keyboardcowboy
      Senior Member
      • Apr 2006
      • 73

      #3
      Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

      But the neutral wire carries no charge,i have touched it and didn't get any shock whereas the hot wire shocks

      Comment

      • pentium
        Badcaps Legend
        • Mar 2006
        • 2778
        • Canada

        #4
        Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

        well there goes my theory on electronics.
        Find Nedry!


        Check the Vending machines!!

        <----Computer says I need more beer.

        Comment

        • willawake
          Super Modulator
          • Nov 2003
          • 8457
          • Greece

          #5
          Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

          well simply...live carries ac current to the equipment and neutral takes it back
          you can reverse live and neutral at the plug, otherwise plugs would only fit in one way

          but you should not assume that neutral does not carry a charge. you should not assume that any circuit is properly wired and safe until it has been proven to be so.
          Last edited by willawake; 01-14-2007, 01:00 PM.
          capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

          Comment

          • gonzo0815
            Badcaps Legend
            • Feb 2006
            • 1600

            #6
            Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

            Well, if you consider the neutral wire as a middle point, you shure can conect either a negative voltage to the live wire or a positive compared to the potential of the neutral wire.
            This is not comparable with an simple battery sheme, where you have only one positive potential. This is not symetrical.
            IMHO AC it is not the same like switching the polarity of a battery. Immagine two bottle, one is positive the other negative compared to the neutral.
            If you conect alternating on of those bottles to the live wire, you have a symetrical AC current, but no voltage on neutral, if all apliances are safe and ok.
            This is exactly, what is the AC current from the mains.
            If you charge two capacitors, the one with the first halve of the the sine wave (positive compared to neutral), the other with the second halve you have the doubled line voltage between them.
            google a littel abouth symetrical sine waves, or just pic an shematic from a symetricaly powered op-, pre- or poweramplifier. Than you will easily see, what is the difference betwen symetric and none symetric currents.

            Comment

            • keyboardcowboy
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2006
              • 73

              #7
              Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

              but what happens when AC alternates shouldn't the live wire become neutral and the neutral wire live then.

              Comment

              • Lonnie
                Member
                • Dec 2006
                • 10

                #8
                Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                The white wire is the GROUNDED wire, the bare copper wire is the GROUNDING wire. They both connect to the neutral buss in the service box. Power does not come from the ground. If you grab the white wire after a load and your body provides sufficient earth ground, you are DEAD.

                Three wires come into the service box: black 115V, red 115V, (each connecting to a separate buss) and the bare grounded wire. Every other circuit breaker on one side of the service box connects to the opposite hot (115V) buss. A 220V breaker occupies two spots on one side of the box taking two 115V lines to a 220V outlet.

                AC current alternates between positive and negetive, the negetive is still positive with respect to ground. If the current stopped flowing every time the cycle went negetive you would have a half wave rectifier.

                Anyone may feel free to correct me if I am wrong, I have very thick skin...
                Last edited by Lonnie; 01-23-2007, 06:20 AM.

                Comment

                • starfury1
                  Badcaps Legend
                  • May 2006
                  • 1256

                  #9
                  Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                  Humm A common enough question, and a not so easy one to answer


                  but what happens when AC alternates shouldn't the live wire become neutral and the neutral wire live then.
                  No current just changes direction,
                  The Active line potential difference in volts with respect to Neutral line goes negative or positive of our Neutral return line.

                  The Neutral line is connected at some point to true earth, the ground on which you stand


                  Current does flow in the neutral and the ground as well
                  it gets very complex how it all works

                  If you want little more read what I have posted below, I will see if I can find some links that explain it all better then I have.

                  Bear in mind I am going to lie to you to some extent and yeah its a long winded answer but I hope it makes things clearer

                  The neutral wire is connected at some point to true earth
                  the earth (as in ground you stand on) is used as the return wire for the AC System


                  (Same idea as a car battery.....just connect one side to the battery to frame of the car, this is dc thought and yes in the past positive of battery has been connected to the car frame ...there are technical reasons why this scheme was used)

                  So the only way you will get a shock is to touch the active wire.

                  Why cause anything else you touch is at earth potential
                  The same potential as neutral line, its earthed


                  Now if you are insulated and you are not touching anything that is earthed and hold on to the Active wire...trust me you will not get a shock.... you will not even get a tingle
                  In short you wont be aware of it at all


                  BUT you will be live at potential difference in volts of 110 Volts or 240Volts AC WITH RESPECT TO EARTH or the neutral.

                  ****** FOR SAFETY'S SAKE DO NOT TRY THIS *********



                  Why is it birds can sit on power lines?

                  Cause they have no connection to earth therefore they will exist at say 110 volts with respect to earth

                  This is how people get killed
                  Not knowing they are live then touching say a water tap or something that is earthed

                  Most common for this is washing machines who's metal case has become live due to wear on the active line (or whatever)

                  We now come to the next part,

                  The reason you get a shock is because of CURRENT flow.

                  Current flows via your body between the Active and Neutral (usually earth in the case above.)
                  You must of course be connected to both


                  The key thing here is that POTENTIAL DIFFERENCE measured in Volts
                  and CURRENT measured in Amperes

                  Are two different entities with electricity
                  (or you should for you mind model consider it that way)

                  So PD Voltage exists across two points
                  Current Amps flows from one point to the other via a conductor.

                  A conductor is anything that will allow current to flow between the PD source
                  All conductors will have some opposition, resistance to current flow


                  Now back to our bird

                  If I take an insulated copper wire, bare one end and tie it to the birds neck then take the other end bare that and stick it in the ground with a metal stake.
                  Then let the bird fly up and land on the power line, it will now become the conductor between active and neutral...and one fried bird
                  or we can think of the bird as a resistive load on the active and neutral.

                  So to summarize;

                  In order to get current flow through a conductor we need a potential different between to points. the neutral and everything else is at or very close to the same PD therefore no current flow..well not enough to give you a shock anyway

                  As to AC

                  If I take two 9 volt batteries (B1 B2) and tie the positive of B2 to the negative of B1
                  (this is called series aiding)

                  Then call that point neutral, zero volts or earth.
                  (we will pretend this point is connected to the earth we stand on and that the other end of the lt bulb is stuck in the ground)


                  I then take a lt bulb and connect one side to this point 0V neutral earth and then connect the other side of the light bulb "alternatively" to first the positive of B1 then the negative B2 and keep repeating this action I will have alternating current flow in the light bulb.


                  most of the above is only to convey the concepts, its not the technical reality of things OK

                  It could have been better structured too.

                  Hope it helps you and doesn't confuse you

                  was looking for some good links that could explain this simply but as yet none Iam happy with ..here's a wiki HIH

                  wiki

                  Cheers
                  You step into the Road, and if you don't keep your feet, there is no knowing where you may be swept off to." Bilbo Baggins ...

                  Comment

                  • keyboardcowboy
                    Senior Member
                    • Apr 2006
                    • 73

                    #10
                    Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                    that cleared my head a bit

                    Comment

                    • Tom41
                      Badcaps Veteran
                      • Oct 2005
                      • 336
                      • England

                      #11
                      Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                      Originally posted by willawake
                      you can reverse live and neutral at the plug, otherwise plugs would only fit in one way
                      Actually that's not true. Most mains plugs will only fit into the socket one way round. The UK standard 3-pin plug has an earth pin that ensures you can only put the plug in the right way round. Likewise, in the US the pins are angled so that you can't put the plug in upside down. It's a very bad idea to reverse live and neutral, as the devices will be set up to take current from the live and pass it through to the neutral. If you put it in backwards, the capacitors and regulators will be powered backwards and could cause an explosion!

                      I remember a demonstration on TV where they rigged up a mains wire so you could switch off either the live or neutral lines. They switched off the neutral, the connected device (a table lamp) went off - but checking with an electrician's test probe, there was still current going to the lamp. Then they turned on the neutral line and switched off the live - this time, the test probe gave no indication of the appliance being live.

                      My father was once asked by a group of students why birds don't get electrocuted when sitting on power lines, and gave the no-ground explanation. Later on, he saw those students by a railroad track, jumping on and off the live rail - without getting electrocuted!
                      Speaking of which, regarding rail/tram tracks... usually, the neutral return line is through one of the running rails. If you step on the neutral rail (even while grounded) you will not feel anything - but step on the live rail, and you'll get a shock. This is especially noticeable with trams that get their power from an overhead wire. Touch the overhead wire and you'll get shocked, but you won't get shocked if you touch the rails - even if a tram has just passed!
                      Last edited by Tom41; 02-04-2007, 12:50 PM.
                      You know there's something wrong when you open your PC and it has vented Rubycons...

                      Comment

                      • gonzo0815
                        Badcaps Legend
                        • Feb 2006
                        • 1600

                        #12
                        Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                        In Germany at least, the wallplugs are not coded in any way. So you can plug the conector in any direction and alternating the neutral and live wire.
                        The conector features two safety ground contacts, wich do conect the device to ground regardles if it is rotated by 180°
                        Some HIFI enthusiasts marke their equipment, to avoid different conected device in their stack.
                        If this benefits in any way, i have no clue.

                        Comment

                        • willawake
                          Super Modulator
                          • Nov 2003
                          • 8457
                          • Greece

                          #13
                          Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                          its the same all over europe i believe. except for those countries that follow the UK method, malta, cyprus? (which i forgot...)

                          i doubt they would do UK specific psus on equipment these days. just add a different plug. Interesting also that UK plugs have a fuse whilst european do not.
                          capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

                          Comment

                          • Galvanized
                            Badcaps Veteran
                            • Mar 2006
                            • 468

                            #14
                            Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                            Originally posted by gonzo0815
                            In Germany at least, the wallplugs are not coded in any way. So you can plug the conector in any direction and alternating the neutral and live wire.
                            The conector features two safety ground contacts, wich do conect the device to ground regardles if it is rotated by 180°
                            Some HIFI enthusiasts marke their equipment, to avoid different conected device in their stack.
                            If this benefits in any way, i have no clue.
                            If the hot and common are reversed and the operator is grounded, a slight tingling sensation can be felt when the equipment's metal case is rubbed.
                            I have read this posted concerning metal comp cases here in The States.

                            I check my outlets with a test probe before hooking up gear. I was told to do it long ago and I still do it.

                            Comment

                            • willawake
                              Super Modulator
                              • Nov 2003
                              • 8457
                              • Greece

                              #15
                              Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                              isnt that actually when the ground is poor or non existent?
                              capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

                              Comment

                              • Galvanized
                                Badcaps Veteran
                                • Mar 2006
                                • 468

                                #16
                                Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                                I would say yes will, when my body offers a lower resistance ground than what is offered at the socket. I have been shocked by electric drills and impact wrenches that had metal bodies but only when the hot & common were reversed. My feet / boots were wet as were my hands.
                                Over at AnandTech a fello had the hot / common reversed and was getting buzzed by his comp case. The wall socket was ungrounded.

                                I remember carlo was running ungrounded at his home. Gabe explains virtual grounding on page two. It is a way to protect connected, yet ungroundable hardware. http://hardwaresecrets.com/article/18

                                I was told that proper grounding offers a path to the static charge built up by spinning opticals and HDDs.
                                I don't know how true it is but I did read that some of the early suspended HDD failures were due to being ungrounded. Some HDDs do have a male blade connector for grounding.

                                Comment

                                • willawake
                                  Super Modulator
                                  • Nov 2003
                                  • 8457
                                  • Greece

                                  #17
                                  Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                                  damn thing is when i receive that no ground buzz i usually am under an office table and bang my head in reaction. i am a little short on braincells after all these years, i hope all the good ones are in the center and dont get damaged from this.

                                  i have soldered a few boards on an ungrounded socket before i realised. can get a buzz if my face touches some metal on the board while i am doing that. i will measure the voltage coming off the tip sometime......
                                  capacitor lab yachtmati techmati

                                  Comment

                                  • gonzo0815
                                    Badcaps Legend
                                    • Feb 2006
                                    • 1600

                                    #18
                                    Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                                    I have tried it, bit the voltage is probably not measuable with a common DVM. probably you need the oscope to carry with you.

                                    Comment

                                    • japlytic
                                      Badcaps Legend
                                      • Oct 2005
                                      • 2086
                                      • Australia

                                      #19
                                      Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                                      There should be near full voltage between Live and Earth, and no more than 0.5VAC between Neutral and Earth. If you get anything different, call an electrician.
                                      A warning for service personnel on a 2-pin AC adaptor telling that the input is not polarized and the fuse may "appear" in the neutral position.
                                      I have seen 2-pin figure-8 connectors on AC adaptors which a corresponding lead can only be inserted one way (one side is square with the other side round).
                                      My first choice in quality Japanese electrolytics is Nippon Chemi-Con, which has been in business since 1931... the quality of electronics is dependent on the quality of the electrolytics.

                                      Comment

                                      • Per Hansson
                                        Super Moderator
                                        • Jul 2005
                                        • 5895
                                        • Sweden

                                        #20
                                        Re: Alternating current & neutral wire

                                        The connectors used in Sweden can be inserted any way. (while still being grounded)

                                        I do not understand how there can be a difference really, it's AC afterall, one big sinus wave moving between a couple hundred volt + and -

                                        If someone could sometime explain to me how AC _really_ works I'd give them a cookie

                                        I still to this day have big problems understanding it...
                                        "The one who says it cannot be done should never interrupt the one who is doing it."

                                        Comment

                                        Related Topics

                                        Collapse

                                        • Document Archive
                                          Surface Mount Fuses Fundamentals Datasheet
                                          by Document Archive
                                          TE Circuit Protection offers the widest selection of surface-mount fuses available for addressing a broad range of overcurrent protection applications. Helping to prevent costly damage and promote a safe environment for electronic and electrical equipment, our single-use chip fuses provide performance stability to support applications with current ratings from .5A up to 20A.

                                          TE Circuit Protection also offers the telecom FT600 fuse for telecommunications applications. This telecom fuse helps comply with North American overcurrent protection requirements, including Telcordia, GR-1089,...
                                          10-07-2024, 06:07 AM
                                        • sam_sam_sam
                                          Is there any high current pouch battery that are size 60mmX80mm maximum thickness 21mm for a battery operated tab welder
                                          by sam_sam_sam
                                          I have a battery operated tab welder and the battery does not have enough current for the battery tab welder because after about 30 welded it does not have the same current output it voltage has gone down by at least 0.500 volts or maybe a more than that

                                          I can fit 21700 battery cells in the enclosure it is very tight fit for four of them that are 35 amp high current capacity 35X4=140 high current output this should work a lot better than what is installed right now

                                          I tested the battery cells there are installed right now and they are testing good with no issues that I...
                                          02-04-2025, 08:08 PM
                                        • Document Archive
                                          Diodes AP21X2SG-13 AP21X2MPG-13 Current Limited Power Switch for Laptop Computer Datasheet
                                          by Document Archive
                                          The AP2182 and AP2192 (AP21X2SG-13 AP21X2MPG-13) are integrated high-side power switches optimized for Universal Serial Bus (USB) and other hot-swap applications. The family of devices complies with USB 2.0 and available with both polarities of Enable input. They offer current and thermal limiting and short circuit protection as well as controlled rise time and under-voltage lockout functionality. A 7ms deglitch capability on the open-drain Flag output prevents false over-current reporting and does not require any external components.

                                          All AP21X2SG-13 AP21X2MPG-13 devices are available...
                                          10-23-2024, 03:33 AM
                                        • DynaxSC
                                          Extreme High Current & Low Voltage Short Killer ??
                                          by DynaxSC
                                          Hi Folks

                                          I'm looking for a extreme high current short killer solution for a reasonable cost.

                                          I have an LGA1700 motherboard (ASUS PRIME Z790-P WiFi) where I exchanged the LGA socket already 3 times, and every time after the socket exchange I get a short of power supply lines VCORE (V variable) and VCCIN_AUX (1.8V).
                                          After taking off the socket, the shorts dissappear again.
                                          The soldermask on the socket is already partially demaged from the heat, so I have reconstructed the soldermask by manually painting the missing soldermask parts with a very small top of a...
                                          10-15-2024, 10:13 AM
                                        • edugimeno
                                          Fancoil.controller with current issues
                                          by edugimeno
                                          Hi there! One friend called to say his fancoill (used for a main access cold Air courtain) controller caught fire, and asking if I could recover the half burnt board
                                          He said the design was too bad as this thing was probably designed for hot water only, as the board was places right underneath the condenser radiators
                                          I found some burnt traces and after a quick Google search for the board name (Pwr-05v-w) I could see an image of the original I was able to find where the original traces were going
                                          The scheme seems simple, from what I understand mains gets into the while 3 lead...
                                          07-26-2024, 01:02 AM
                                        • Loading...
                                        • No more items.
                                        Working...