DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Crystaleyes
    Badcaps Veteran
    • Sep 2021
    • 493
    • Brazil

    #1

    DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

    A bit of a random question, but I was just wondering about the feasibilty/reality of buiding a valve tester?

    This is something I have never looked into, but seems like here would be a good place to ask.

    Anyone here ever done (or tried to do) this?
  • eccerr0r
    Solder Sloth
    • Nov 2012
    • 8670
    • USA

    #2
    Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

    for specific tubes, it's been done; for general tubes... that has always been a problem. All those pinout charts are there for a reason, including those ancient kiosks that have a hundred sockets because of the pinout problem...
    BTW that's just if you just want emission only; versus if characterization tracing/gm/... is also needed, that's even harder to make a general solution.

    Comment

    • Crystaleyes
      Badcaps Veteran
      • Sep 2021
      • 493
      • Brazil

      #3
      Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

      So far, I've never 'worked' with any valve system, other than swapping the valves on our guitar amps, back in the day... However, I do keep coming across them on sale for pennies in the local street markets and it would be good to have a simple way to verify whether they are good or not, without having to splash out on a Hickok or similar.

      Might be a good little earner, as some valves are not cheap.

      Comment

      • stj
        Great Sage 齊天大聖
        • Dec 2009
        • 30937
        • Albion

        #4
        Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

        you can get schematics of old testers,
        as for the 100 sockets/pinouts issue, you could use a load of relays and a microcontroller to configure the pinouts

        Comment

        • eccerr0r
          Solder Sloth
          • Nov 2012
          • 8670
          • USA

          #5
          Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

          Effectively you'd need a n^2 switch tree where n is the max number of pins plus top caps...

          I suspect if you want to make a tester solely for 6BQ5, 12AX7, and 6146B's it'd make things a lot easier.

          BTW I have a portable tube tester but it's short/open/emission-only and only has the common 1930's+ tubes I think. Uses multiposition switches to deal with the n^2 relay bank mess and very manual... Good enough for go/no go, but can't match tubes.
          Last edited by eccerr0r; 07-11-2023, 02:06 PM.

          Comment

          • eccerr0r
            Solder Sloth
            • Nov 2012
            • 8670
            • USA

            #6
            Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

            So which tubes are people still interested in?

            TBH I don't think I'm really interested in any tubes though the 6146's are still kind of interesting (as a ham). Which incidentally my tube tester cannot test... Alas I don't have any of these, just the cheap old 12AX7's, 12BA6's, 12BE6's, 50C5's, 35W4's, 12AT6's, ...

            Comment

            • Crystaleyes
              Badcaps Veteran
              • Sep 2021
              • 493
              • Brazil

              #7
              Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

              Thanks for all the input, it was just an idea... I still think that if I come across another box of dirt cheap valves then I'll pick them up, if only just to offer them to a wider public.

              I often see valves such the 12AX7's and the like for a Euro (or less) which will just get binned if no-one buys them.

              Comment

              • eccerr0r
                Solder Sloth
                • Nov 2012
                • 8670
                • USA

                #8
                Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

                As with any goods, tubes are expensive only if demand exceeds supply ...
                probably zillions of 12AX7's out there but thought there was still a demand for them as they make good preamps that give people the "tube sound" (what?) experience.

                Alas I'm all solid state for audio, don't give a crap about "tube sound". But 6146's are blown quite frequently trying to make another contact...

                (the 12BA6's, 12BE6's, 50C5's, 35W4's, 12AT6's are all used for AA5 radios and since there were a zillion of these around, there are zillions of these tubes around, and thus likewise worthless. And who uses AA5 radios anymore, even if it's for AM...)

                Comment

                • stj
                  Great Sage 齊天大聖
                  • Dec 2009
                  • 30937
                  • Albion

                  #9
                  Re: DIY valve tester - Is it worth it?

                  there are huge stocks of valves in eastern europe, but postage would be a bitch.
                  and huge piles of boxed spares dumped in abandoned soviet bases too - seen video of it.
                  they prefered valves over transistors because they are less effected by emp etc.

                  Comment

                  Related Topics

                  Collapse

                  • Zoea
                    6p3p*2 Class A valve amp - put the wrong valves in - it's broken...
                    by Zoea
                    Hi there

                    I'm new to this forum and a bit of a newb at repair so please be kind

                    I have a class A valve amp bought from ebay based on the 6p3p and 6N1 valves. I believe it was based on a kit from SiliconRay and I bought it from UK ebay prebuild.

                    Here is a video and here is the thread that seems to be authoritative for the kit.

                    The circuit diagram is there in the thread, though apparently there was a second version of the circuit as I recently saw another ebay listing mentioning this.

                    Long story short, I had a small problem...
                    11-03-2020, 10:15 AM
                  • sam_sam_sam
                    Component tester which one is worth the money from it capability to test and identify
                    by sam_sam_sam
                    I am thinking of buying a component tester but I want to get the most out of the device for the money that I am going to spend

                    Any idea but I would prefer actual use of the device it good points and it short comings be completely truthful about the review of the device

                    There are so many versions of this type of device and I do not have enough information to make a good decision at this point

                    When I bought my battery testing machine I had some information to go by because of electrical experience with auto electrical experience in this field job wise (...
                    06-30-2022, 08:23 PM
                  • CuriousJohn
                    Burco boiler power problem
                    by CuriousJohn
                    Burco BCPLSAFWM5L 5 Litre Wall Mounted Automatic Water Boiler With Filtration UK 240v

                    Does anybody have any experience with these Burco units at all there is no record of them on the forum lol and a proper service manual would be nice. I invite you all to pesuade me not to botch repair it with a 5v relay, read on.

                    This unit was rescued from a skip 3 years ago, the only fault it had then was no backight display (plus it wanted a new probe set and top seal) but the screen was never an issue you can still see the screen as is and I just use it to get 5 Litres of very hot...
                    12-22-2024, 10:25 AM
                  • Lifeisfun
                    Trying to troubleshoot DDR4 SODIMM slot with slot tester
                    by Lifeisfun
                    Hi folks!
                    I have some kind of memory problem on Lenovo laptop. I was initially able to install windows after several tries since the laptop did freeze in middle of those attempts.
                    Eventually I discovered that it was related to moving the laptop.
                    Later on it even stopped booting unless I pressed around the memory slot. (no keyboard LEDs only power button responds)
                    If I remove the RAM I get the beeps that RAM is missing. Inserting the RAM there is silence and it will not boot most of the time. No picture.

                    I removed the board got one of those memory slot testers...
                    06-04-2025, 02:26 PM
                  • spleenharvester
                    Reverse engineering of 18650 4-channel tester
                    by spleenharvester
                    Hi friends

                    I have reverse engineered this tester, schematic is attached and is complete except for capacitor values. These testers annoyingly have no model number but they are the ones you find on the first page of just about any website if you type in "18650 4-channel tester". There is also a 2-channel variant and a newer 8-channel variant. They are very cheap (about £15) and can measure voltage, current, internal resistance and capacity. They have a multicolour display for all these statistics. They also have terminal blocks so that if you want to use a breakout board...
                    05-04-2025, 02:43 AM
                  • Loading...
                  • No more items.
                  Working...